Not even close, Quartey wins all day. I feel he would also beat Cotto, Margarito and probably even Pacquiao at his best, at welter. That may not be a concensus, but I don't think there's any question that Ike fought in a better era for the weight class. Cotto Pacquiao Margo and even Mayweather(though he's the only one I'd really give a chance to dominate) really don't measure up to what the division had in the mid 90s to early 2000s... Prime Oscar, Mosley, Trinidad, Quartey and Vargas were a notch above for me.