I think Zab Judah had actual boxing talent and at times he refused to throw punches, he refused to be active in the ring, and he got cocky plenty of times and it cost him: Tszyu, Spinks (he could have EASILY won that first fight), Baldomir, and hell had he been 100% focused vs Floyd he could have won that fight.

McCall as Manny Steward said "Was just a club fighter"....he had big power, a great chin, but no real SKILL. He got lucky vs Lewis, he probably could have been managed better but that's about it.