I don't think Oscar was shot when he fought Floyd at all. I think more than anything he wasn't very sharp due to only fighting twice since 2004. After losing to BHop he didn't fight for almost 2 years when he came back vs Mayorga. Right after that he went and fought the top fighter in the world. It was dumb on his part. The bigger mistake he made was coming down to fight Pacman at 142lb. He already lost the fight before he entered the ring. Oscar hadn't been that light since 1997!!!

I don't believe the argument that Pacman fought a "more shot" Oscar than Floyd did. It was only a year and a half later and Oscar fought once. Oscar was a round away from getting the node vs Floyd and Pacman dominated de la Hoya. Mayweather fought him at a resonable weight for Oscar but that's about it. Having seen what Manny has been doing to larger fighter later I think he still dominates Oscar if they fought at 150 (like Floyd did) or even 154.