Why is lil floid on the P4P list at all in 2011...

[marbleheadmaui]

Ring Magazine P4P for April 2011. Here's a screenshot:




BoxRec inexplicably currently has lil floid #1 at Welterweight.

I don't see how 2 fights in 3½ years warrants any Top 5 ranking at all.

One fight was against a fat, old Featherweight, career 126 pounder who floid called all the way up to Welterweight, against whom floid weighed in a few lbs over the contracted weight and still danced to a sleep-inducing 12 rd decision.

The 2nd fight was to a 38 year old shadow of Shane Mosley who still almost cracked lil floid out of there inside of 2 rds.

the same old Featherweight that had just gotten robbed by Pacquiao a year earlier and the same old Shane Mosley who Pacquiao is now facing and his fanboys are trying to hype up as a legitimate challenge, it goes both ways buddy

and Floyd is listed as #1 at welterweight because he's still the Lineal Welterweight Champion, unlike Manny who just holds a strap

The bold is just incorrect. The boxrec formula gives no weight to titles/belts etc. It is straight math.