Amanda Knox guilty or not?

[Cressa121]

I find this quite unbelievable from the Daily Mail website. I understand them preparing 2 stories so they can upload it to the site as soon as the verdict was delivered, but come on. Look at those 'quotes'.

Tabloid Watch: MailOnline makes up events, quotes from Perugia

[Master]

She was found guilty for blaming a completely innocent man and implicated him for the murder. She was out on a technicality and she did it with the other 2.

[armyash]

She was found guilty for blaming a completely innocent man and implicated him for the murder. She was out on a technicality and she did it with the other 2.

Yeah out on a technicality i agree. dna evidence was not strong enough blah blah, if she was innocent surely her dna wouldn't have been on the knife near the girls body at all. It frustrates me that she told so many lies and changed her story on different occasions while having evidence going against her and still get off with it.

I haven't heard much about the ivory coast guy who is still inside for it, he's obviously a killer but don't seem like he has tried to implicate knox and her bloke too severly that goes in her favour but i doubt he is given much opportunity to speak to the media.

it's merediths family i feel sorry for big time couldn't imagine what it like to go through what they been through but makes it even worse when the killer got away with it.

[generalbulldog]

She was found guilty for blaming a completely innocent man and implicated him for the murder. She was out on a technicality and she did it with the other 2.

Yep. She blamed her boss at first and said he was the murderer, not only that but she changed her story a lot of times. Innocent people dont change their stories constantly.

[ICB]

Guilty as sin.

[imp]

Money can get anyone off.
Knox is as guilty as sin.
But they have the poor black guy to take the fall so this will all fade away and amanda will get very rich and the real killer.. a thing of the past.
Bring on 2012 and the end of this system of things

[Kev]

Money can get anyone off.
Knox is as guilty as sin.
But they have the poor black guy to take the fall so this will all fade away and amanda will get very rich and the real killer.. a thing of the past.
Bring on 2012 and the end of this system of things

Based on what? What evidence against her convinces you of her guilt?

Or have you just bought into the media headlines of the last four years?

[imp]

Money can get anyone off.
Knox is as guilty as sin.
But they have the poor black guy to take the fall so this will all fade away and amanda will get very rich and the real killer.. a thing of the past.
Bring on 2012 and the end of this system of things

Based on what? What evidence
against her convinces you of her
guilt?

Or have you just bought into the
media headlines of the last four
years?

What makes you think shes completely innocent Bilbo?

Sorry to ask a question with a question.

[BIG H]

She was found guilty for blaming a completely innocent man and implicated him for the murder. She was out on a technicality and she did it with the other 2.

Yep. She blamed her boss at first and said he was the murderer, not only that but she changed her story a lot of times. Innocent people dont change their stories constantly.

Desperate people may do, whether guilty or not.

[Kev]

The people who are saying she is guilty as sin though, based on what?

As I understand there is no evidence whatsoever linking her to the murder.

Her DNA was not found anywhere in the room where Meredith was killed, whereas Randy Guede's was found all over Meredith's body.

Meredith has been determined as a killer based on her contradictory reports as to what happened that night, blaming her boss, reported unusual behaviour and a the inconsistent alibi story.

As H says, that may have been desperation and fear rather than guilt. It's also worth noting she was only 19/20 at the time, didn't speak much Italian and the whole interview took place, supposedly under duress and in a foreign language.

I guess her story will come out in time.

IT's very similar to that poor backpacker girl whose husband/fiance was murdered when they were both kidnapped in the outback. For years she was regarded as being complicit as it was 'impossible' she could have escaped as she described.

Then in court, they handcuffed her from behind and asked her to demonstrate how she managed to escape. She just sat down on the floor and slid the cuffs under her legs and was able to run away. Took about 4 seconds....

The media print a lot of sensationalist crap and twist every innocent thing to be malevolent.

[Mars_ax]

"Foxy Knoxy"?, this bitch is seriously ugly, and humm, a horrible speaker.

Amanda Knox's tearful return to the U.S.

[Kev]

"Foxy Knoxy"?, this bitch is seriously ugly, and humm, a horrible speaker.

Amanda Knox's tearful return to the U.S.

First speech after 4 years in prison with the world hating you, not easy to look your best.

Also, horrible speaker? Imagine how most of us would sound after 4 years inside for murder and the media scrutiny she has endured. You can't exactly expect her to sound like Clarence Darrow.
By Christmas she will be a hottie again.

[Fenster]

I think Bilbo and H are right here. Joanna Lees (backpack murder) was guilty as hell in the media until it turned out she was innocent.

Ever heard about the West Memphis Three? These poor fuckers just spent 20 years in prison basically on the back of a borderline retarded kids "confession." Convicted with ZERO evidence or motive.

[Mars_ax]

I think Bilbo and H are right here. Joanna Lees (backpack murder) was guilty as hell in the media until it turned out she was innocent.

Ever heard about the West Memphis Three? These poor fuckers just spent 20 years in prison basically on the back of a borderline retarded kids "confession." Convicted with ZERO evidence or motive.

Knox may or may not really be guilty, the bottom line is, the Italian prosecutions flimsy "evidence" against her should never have supported a murder conviction in the first place.

[Andre]

I find this quite unbelievable from the Daily Mail website. I understand them preparing 2 stories so they can upload it to the site as soon as the verdict was delivered, but come on. Look at those 'quotes'.

Tabloid Watch: MailOnline makes up events, quotes from Perugia

Wow. believe nothing.