Does James Toney Have The Best Ever Chin In Boxing ?

[p4pking]

Smokin' Joe had the best chin I'd ever seen and I said that way before his death too. The shots he was taking from Foreman would have killed most other men. Joe just got up and got on with it until the ref stepped in. Toney does have a great chin but Joe would never have been floored by a 168lbs Roy Jones, that shot would have bounced off!

Sorry, but I think you really are saying that because Frazier just died. It's akin to saying Roy Jones would've never been hurt by Oscar Larios so he has a better chin than Wayne McCullough. For that matter I don't think any little men can really be in the discussion for best chins because people that size generate exponentailly less power than big men, while still having basically the same mechanism to absorb punches. Toney wasn't hurt by Roy Jones either, that KD was entirely balance and chin doesn't even really come into play imo. For James Toney to have taken the punches that he did at HW clearly puts him amongst the toughest men to ever box at a high level imo.

[denilson200]

Toney is certainly up there. He's one of the toughest men to ever box.

Chavez, Mike Tyson, Oliver McCall all had great chins as well.

I would not put Iron Mike in a list of all time great chins. McCall, Chavez yes...I would also add B-Hop in there too, I don't even think I've even seen B-Hop hurt, never mind knocked down or KO-ed.

[brocktonblockbust]

this forum doesnt know me 2 b rude but to answer this op question : FUCK NO!
NOT A GOOD QUESTION, SORRY.

[Hulk]

Toney is certainly up there. He's one of the toughest men to ever box.

Chavez, Mike Tyson, Oliver McCall all had great chins as well.

I would not put Iron Mike in a list of all time great chins. McCall, Chavez yes...I would also add B-Hop in there too, I don't even think I've even seen B-Hop hurt, never mind knocked down or KO-ed.

I love Hopkins, but did you miss the first Pascal fight where he was dropped twice ?

Or the Segundo Mercado fight where he was dropped ?

Or the Antwun Echols fight where he was cheap shotted and dropped ?

[MonsonFan]

Hagler