Steve Smoger felt Margarito was turning the tide when the doctor robbed Margarito

[CFH]

If you spend the whole fight getting puched in the face you have only yourself to blame for the loss.

Best post I've read in a while.

[Violent Demise]

If you spend the whole fight getting puched in the face you have only yourself to blame for the loss.

Thank you. So why exactly is Margarito-Cotto 1 debated again?

[Preme]

Smoger is a very respected ref. His opinion is well valued. It's to bad he didn't get to make the final decision. Cuz I too saw the fight starting to change. Cotto was already starting to back up in that moronic fashion of his. Had the fight gone on I think he would of just hung on and made it to the bell to take a points victory. But I doubt he cries like a bitch in celebration afterwards.

I like a ref who lets a fighter fight as much as the next guy, but this is the same idiot who let let Gatti get battered by Gomez; who would have let it continue until the coroner carted his body out in a ba. If Hazzard hadn't intervened in that massacre who knows how long Smoger would have stood by with his thumb up his ass!

Granted I think Margarito should have been left to continue, but using Smoger's decision making as the basis of your argument is laughable. Although laughable is the bearing of the majority of your posts.

[Violent Demise]

Smoger is a very respected ref. His opinion is well valued. It's to bad he didn't get to make the final decision. Cuz I too saw the fight starting to change. Cotto was already starting to back up in that moronic fashion of his. Had the fight gone on I think he would of just hung on and made it to the bell to take a points victory. But I doubt he cries like a bitch in celebration afterwards.

I like a ref who lets a fighter fight as much as the next guy, but this is the same idiot who let let Gatti get battered by Gomez; who would have let it continue until the coroner carted his body out in a ba. If Hazzard hadn't intervened in that massacre who knows how long Smoger would have stood by with his thumb up his ass!

Granted I think Margarito should have been left to continue, but using Smoger's decision making as the basis of your argument is laughable. Although laughable is the bearing of the majority of your posts.

No it was not. Again you show how pathetic your boxing knowledge is. Smoger didn't call Gatti-Gomez. It was Randy Neuman. Stupid muthafukka. Go back to being the cool guy who buys beer and gets drunk with a bunch of 15 year old boys. To them ther's no one cooler than you. '

[Preme]

Smoger is a very respected ref. His opinion is well valued. It's to bad he didn't get to make the final decision. Cuz I too saw the fight starting to change. Cotto was already starting to back up in that moronic fashion of his. Had the fight gone on I think he would of just hung on and made it to the bell to take a points victory. But I doubt he cries like a bitch in celebration afterwards.

I like a ref who lets a fighter fight as much as the next guy, but this is the same idiot who let let Gatti get battered by Gomez; who would have let it continue until the coroner carted his body out in a ba. If Hazzard hadn't intervened in that massacre who knows how long Smoger would have stood by with his thumb up his ass!

Granted I think Margarito should have been left to continue, but using Smoger's decision making as the basis of your argument is laughable. Although laughable is the bearing of the majority of your posts.

No it was not. Again you show how pathetic your boxing knowledge is. Smoger didn't call Gatti-Gomez. It was Randy Neuman. Stupid muthafukka. Go back to being the cool guy who buys beer and gets drunk with a bunch of 15 year old boys. To them ther's no one cooler than you. '

Don't I look silly

[Violent Demise]

Smoger is a very respected ref. His opinion is well valued. It's to bad he didn't get to make the final decision. Cuz I too saw the fight starting to change. Cotto was already starting to back up in that moronic fashion of his. Had the fight gone on I think he would of just hung on and made it to the bell to take a points victory. But I doubt he cries like a bitch in celebration afterwards.

I like a ref who lets a fighter fight as much as the next guy, but this is the same idiot who let let Gatti get battered by Gomez; who would have let it continue until the coroner carted his body out in a ba. If Hazzard hadn't intervened in that massacre who knows how long Smoger would have stood by with his thumb up his ass!

Granted I think Margarito should have been left to continue, but using Smoger's decision making as the basis of your argument is laughable. Although laughable is the bearing of the majority of your posts.

No it was not. Again you show how pathetic your boxing knowledge is. Smoger didn't call Gatti-Gomez. It was Randy Neuman. Stupid muthafukka. Go back to being the cool guy who buys beer and gets drunk with a bunch of 15 year old boys. To them ther's no one cooler than you. '

Don't I look silly

If everybody didn't already know you're a fucking idiot than yeah you would. But good thing for you everybody already knows you're a fucking idiot. So no harm done.

[LobowolfXXX]

As long as they cut the price on the pay per view, I'm ok with Cotto-Margarito III...and IV...and V...and VI. I could watch Cotto kick Margarito's ass every 3 months for the rest of my life.

[InTheNeutralCorner]

As long as they cut the price on the pay per view, I'm ok with Cotto-Margarito III...and IV...and V...and VI. I could watch Cotto kick Margarito's ass every 3 months for the rest of my life.

No, you couldn't. Margarito will be blind after the 3rd fight and will not be allowed to fight again.

[TitoFan]

Smoger is a very respected ref. His opinion is well valued. It's to bad he didn't get to make the final decision. Cuz I too saw the fight starting to change. Cotto was already starting to back up in that moronic fashion of his. Had the fight gone on I think he would of just hung on and made it to the bell to take a points victory. But I doubt he cries like a bitch in celebration afterwards.

Coulda, woulda, shoulda..... Kind of sad seeing you all bitter like that, VD. Tell you what. Why don't you and Outspoken take turns licking Margafucko's balls..... er..... I mean.... wounds.

[ElTerribleMorales]

if by backing up you mean pushing Margarito fucking forward and manhandling him onto the ropes, then yea I saw Cotto starting to do that as well in the 8th and 9th

[Gandalf]

VD is correct. I wholeheartedly agree with him in this thread.

[TitoFan]

If you spend the whole fight getting puched in the face you have only yourself to blame for the loss.

Thank you. So why exactly is Margarito-Cotto 1 debated again?

The only debate I know of from their first fight is that now it's even more probable that Margafucko had been using his plaster wraps BEFORE the Mosley fight.

[ElTerribleMorales]

Smoger is a very respected ref. His opinion is well valued. It's to bad he didn't get to make the final decision. Cuz I too saw the fight starting to change. Cotto was already starting to back up in that moronic fashion of his. Had the fight gone on I think he would of just hung on and made it to the bell to take a points victory. But I doubt he cries like a bitch in celebration afterwards.

you wanna play the card that Cotto "quit", you wanna play it as if he cried like a bitch afterwards, well Mexico's greatest fighter QUIT on his stool refusing to come out cause of a cut against a young DLH, and he CRIED LIKE A BITCH when he lost to fucking Grover, not even gonna bother putting the name down cause you know who it is, and you're probably gonna cry and say, gee whiz his cut needed like 5000 stitches and he lost a gallon of blood, and then say he cried cause his career was over and he lost to a bum, cause it's what you do, you complain bitch and moan, criticize every other fighter yet you put up a million excuses or sugar coat everything when your own boy gets his ass whooped or avoids fighting anyone of worth, you SCREAMED TO THE HEAVENS that Montiel was gonna fuck up Donaire (I picked Montiel to win so no hate from here) yet your first post about the fight afterwards? "ohhh Montiel is shot to shit and too small", get the fuck out of here with that shit dude it's your M.O., all that would have happened had the fight gone any longer is that Margarito would have been blind in his eye, bitching and moaning that Cotto didn't stand right in front of him with his hands tied behind his back and allowed Margarito to wail on him for the first half of the fight, MARGARITO GOT HIS ASS WHOOPED, the tide wasn't turning, Cotto had plenty of stamina left, his legs looked strong as ever and his punches still had plenty of power and sting behind him, Margarito although he was touching him up a bit but it only happened BECAUSE COTTO BY THIS POINT ALREADY DECIDED TO STAND AND TRADE WITH HIM SINCE TONY HAD ZERO POWER, you're like a two yr old kid having a little tantrum cause you had your favorite toy taken away, and it's probably to the same extent seeing how your favorite toy is probably Tony's dick

[Nameless]

ONe is not supposed to get cut bad and all swollen by fists. MArgarito did let it to allow, his plain fault if he couldn't taste the 12 full rounds and see if he could have turned it around.

[LobowolfXXX]

if by backing up you mean pushing Margarito fucking forward and manhandling him onto the ropes, then yea I saw Cotto starting to do that as well in the 8th and 9th

Yes, Margarito was coming on strong late. The 8th and 9th were two of his best rounds; after all, one of the judges gave him one of those rounds.