Prime Hatton VS Maidana

[Nameless]

Somehow, I do see Hatton winning this one while in his prime and where his body wasn't crucially smothered by excessive eating and drinking habits.

[erics44]

Would maidana had have beaten tzu?

[Violent Demise]

Would maidana had have beaten tzu?

No

[Master]

Would maidana had have beaten tzu?

No chance Tszyu prime would batter Maidana as he did Gonzales from pillar to post.

[Slim the BoxingManiac]

I think some of you guys are dramatically overrating Maidana's power and perhaps underrating Hatton's.

Maidana couldn't put a dent in an old, worn Morales and couldn't even put Khan down after he hit him with dozens of shots. He also has zero defense and while he has a good chin he has been hurt by Ortiz, Khan, and Morales.

Hatton would take some damage, but Maidana would take much, much more.

Morales has a good chin, and Khan did well at being particularly slippery on the ropes. While I agree that Maidana's power is overrated, but his punch is still pretty good.

The one point I'm making is that Maidana is a warrior in the ring, and I don't imagine anybody having an easy fight with the guy. His determination makes victory possible.

[FinitoElDinamita]

Would maidana had have beaten tzu?

Yea, if he had fought in Argentina with the referee in his pocket just as Hatton did.
Sure, Maidana could have beaten an over the hill Tszyu under those circumstances.