The Ring - still ranking Khan above Garcia

[roberto duran legend]

Yeah he proved it at the weekend.

[shza]

They do their updates on Tuesdays. Calm down.

[Mark TKO]

They do their updates on Tuesdays. Calm down.

thats just lazy - havent they heard of seven day weeks

[Mark TKO]

Yeah he proved it at the weekend.

I hope Garcia doesn't rematch him

[shza]

They're up now:

Champion: Danny Garcia

1. Lucas Matthysse
2. Amir Khan
3. Zab Judah
4. Juan Manuel Marquez
5. Mike Alvarado
6. Marcos Maidana
7. Erik Morales
8. Khabib Allakhverdiev
9. Denis Shafikov
10. Ajose Olusegun

Personally, I think this is fine except it *really* overrates Judah -- and Khan should probably take more of a hit, though I'm not sure who you'd put ahead of him. I might make JMM #2, despite his lack of experience at the weight, Alvarado 3, Khan 4, Judah 5, and then keep the rest as they are (this in complete igonrance of the guys they've got at 8-10).

Here's their explanation: RING Ratings Update: Where does Khan fit in? | RingTV

[erics44]

if stoke city beat man u they wouldnt be above them in the lb4lb football ratings

khan has had a good run up until garcia, mixing in some top company and only loosing to a cheat since prescott

garcia has also had a good run but not mixed it quite in the same company as khan has

khan probably still deserves to be above garcia

[Mark TKO]

can't compare football and boxing in that respect

[erics44]

can't compare football and boxing in that respect

you can, say a journeyman beat khan, should he be rated above him?

[Seraphanx]

can't compare football and boxing in that respect

you can, say a journeyman beat khan, should he be rated above him?

Probably not, but a fellow champion comparably ranked who beats him should.

If Stoke City were 2 points behind Man Utd and then beat them they would be above them. But you can't compare the two because one uses a subjective ranking sytem and one uses a mathematical points system.