The "Hatton was never comfortable at 147" myth..

[Fenster]

1. Hatton beat Collazo at 147 (If you think he lost? Tough. It was a close fight he won).

2. Hatton couldn't beat Floyd at any weight or at any time in history.

3. If you have a hundred fights at 140 and only two at 147 it's pretty obvious 140 was your prime weight.

4. @Althguz - have you ever made a post without mentioning Calzaghe? Weird boy, very weird

[Master]

Hatton was uncomfortable at 147lb it was not his best weight. I think Hatton could have beaten Floyd at 140lb if it was in England with an English ref.

[Fenster]

Hatton was uncomfortable at 147lb it was not his best weight. I think Hatton could have beaten Floyd at 140lb if it was in England with an English ref.

... and if the English ref DQ'd Floyd after he knocked Hatton out.

[Master]

Hatton was uncomfortable at 147lb it was not his best weight. I think Hatton could have beaten Floyd at 140lb if it was in England with an English ref.

... and if the English ref DQ'd Floyd after he knocked Hatton out.

The ref would never have penalized Hatton and Ricky would not have lost his head mid way into the fight.

[Fenster]

Hatton was uncomfortable at 147lb it was not his best weight. I think Hatton could have beaten Floyd at 140lb if it was in England with an English ref.

... and if the English ref DQ'd Floyd after he knocked Hatton out.

The ref would never have penalized Hatton and Ricky would not have lost his head mid way into the fight.

Yeah.. Hatton would have lost his head early because Floyd would have realised he could get shafted.

[Althugz]

Hatton was uncomfortable at 147lb it was not his best weight. I think Hatton could have beaten Floyd at 140lb if it was in England with an English ref.

... and if the English ref DQ'd Floyd after he knocked Hatton out.

The ref would never have penalized Hatton and Ricky would not have lost his head mid way into the fight.

There's no place, time or dimension that Hatton could have won, Master.

I know it's cliche to say this now but it's so appropriate - "Ricky's dad could have been ref..." you know the rest.

(Actually, you never know..based on recent events Ricky's dad could have turned villain mid way and clotheslined Ricky out of his boots. Maybe even a steel chair shot..) Either way Floyd wins

[THE PHILOSOPHER]

Why do i get dragged into the opening post? I won't dignify u with my thoughts because u can't have a debate without telling someone u 'came' on one of there parents!

[Althugz]

Why do i get dragged into the opening post? I won't dignify u with my thoughts because u can't have a debate without telling someone u 'came' on one of there parents!

Oh don't cry because I countered your irrelevant insult about me wearing "woodstain" with an equally irrelevant jibe back at you.

[Althugz]

1. Hatton beat Collazo at 147 (If you think he lost? Tough. It was a close fight he won).

2. Hatton couldn't beat Floyd at any weight or at any time in history.

3. If you have a hundred fights at 140 and only two at 147 it's pretty obvious 140 was your prime weight.

4. @Althguz - have you ever made a post without mentioning Calzaghe? Weird boy, very weird

1) Actually I thought he won by virtue of the KD - contrary to popular opinion here. He did struggle though and would have at 140 too.

2) True

3) Definitely prime at 140 but I think too much is made of his one loss and one struggle at 147.

4) True, I start "JC Haters" rehab tomorrow. Maybe I secretly am a fan unable to express my true feelings for him. I hope not..