[QUOTE=Violent Demise;1152472]
Quote Originally Posted by Rantcatrat View Post

If Floyd was to beat Martinez next or if he had beaten Cotto or Margarito in 07 I would still rank his win over Corrales as his best ever
Good call @Violent Demise . While I'm not sure that I agree with that statement, I agree that his win over Diego Corrales in 2001 was his career-best win. Corrales was ranked #5 p4p at the time they fought, and many people thought Floyd would lose.

I have a number of questions for you.

Was that win in 2001 at junior lightweight Floyd's best win?

How highly do you rank Corrales compared with other junior lightweights/super featherweights throughout history?

How highly do you rank a victory over Diego Corrales in terms of quality of win? Compare it to wins by other great fighters.

How much differently do you treat Castillo's win over Corrales in their rematch to their epic war? On that same note, how highly do you rank Casamayor's win over Corrales in their third (?) fight?

Even if you think that win would have been better than wins over Martinez at junior middlweight, or Cotto/Margarito in 2007, would those wins not have added a lot to his legacy?