I always go by the record books, because as a boxer you don't have to convince the fans you won, you have to convince 3 judges you won (or be well connected enough to have the judges in your pocket).

But in extreme cases, yeah I will astrix the record. I don't do it with close fights. But we all know Roy Jones beat Park Si Hun. We all know Pernell beat JCC. Ect ect. It's impossible for me to talk about certain records without bringing up the fact that they got a gift or robbed.