Anybody picking Khan over Brook if they fight?

[walrus]

I know I hate him but since when did khan become the master ring general, defensive whizz?

I'm leaning towards you. I am surprised people were getting excited upon the mention of Floyd v Khan. I just don't see Khan doing anything. Khan keeps on giving lackluster performances.

[g3org3]

I know I hate him but since when did khan become the master ring general, defensive whizz?

I'm leaning towards you. I am surprised people were getting excited upon the mention of Floyd v Khan. I just don't see Khan doing anything. Khan keeps on giving lackluster performances.

I think the attraction between floyd vs khan is its somthing we haven't seen before khans faster than floyd and will try to outwork him. I think the only type of fighter that will give floyd problems is a fast puncher with a high work rate and there's only khan and pacman that I would personally want to see floyd face. Every other fighter is a easy fight for floyd

[Dia bando]

Khan all the skills but no chin, Brook would get to him in about 6 rounds, lets be honest bigger
men hit harder, Brook is a light middle that boils down to welter,! advantage to the bigger man.
Lets face fact's Khan can't take light welter punches, and he looks very poor at the higher weight
just a accident waiting to happen.!!!!!

[Primo Carnera]

Anybody would think that Mayweather was slow the way they bang on about Khan's speed. If Khan doesn't fight Mayweather or Brook who does he fight? Brook would be to Strong for Khan, and Khan's name shouldn't even be mentioned in same breath as Mayweather! They're calling out Mayweather because Khan is one more defeat away from oblivion! Let Khan fight Broner. That way at least one myth will be dispelled.

[g3org3]

Anybody would think that Mayweather was slow the way they bang on about Khan's speed. If Khan doesn't fight Mayweather or Brook who does he fight? Brook would be to Strong for Khan, and Khan's name shouldn't even be mentioned in same breath as Mayweather! They're calling out Mayweather because Khan is one more defeat away from oblivion! Let Khan fight Broner. That way at least one myth will be dispelled.

I would pick khan to beat broner as long as he sticks to boxing right now i would say khans the fastest boxer out there also think pacmans slightly faster than floyd.

[smashup]

Anybody would think that Mayweather was slow the way they bang on about Khan's speed. If Khan doesn't fight Mayweather or Brook who does he fight? Brook would be to Strong for Khan, and Khan's name shouldn't even be mentioned in same breath as Mayweather! They're calling out Mayweather because Khan is one more defeat away from oblivion! Let Khan fight Broner. That way at least one myth will be dispelled.

I would pick khan to beat broner as long as he sticks to boxing right now i would say khans the fastest boxer out there also think pacmans slightly faster than floyd.

Both are faster than FM and would make him fight back ,
Its hard to difuse speed like that unless you start to put the guy firmly in his place but hurting him.
This is the appeal of seeing Khan fight anyone ;-)

[Mark TKO]

Nothin to add that hasn't already been said

Khan will dominate early rounds but Brook will catch him eventually.
Would love to see it though

[Primo Carnera]

Anybody would think that Mayweather was slow the way they bang on about Khan's speed. If Khan doesn't fight Mayweather or Brook who does he fight? Brook would be to Strong for Khan, and Khan's name shouldn't even be mentioned in same breath as Mayweather! They're calling out Mayweather because Khan is one more defeat away from oblivion! Let Khan fight Broner. That way at least one myth will be dispelled.

I would pick khan to beat broner as long as he sticks to boxing right now i would say khans the fastest boxer out there also think pacmans slightly faster than floyd.

I possibly agree about Khan vs Broner as long as he keeps out of harms way, but there's always a chance at the top level that the opponent will get his chances and connect and that's where Khan's problems lie. Almost impossible for any fighter to steer clear of his opponent for 12 rounds.
It's more about how you react to getting hurt. Unfortunately Khan's instinct is to act brave and try to "War it out" and even encourage your opponent on despite the fact that your legs are wobbling. Other boxers, even including Mayweather instinctively either hold on or avoid further punches until their head is cleared. What Khan needs to realise (and I don't think he ever will!) is that there is no shame in getting hurt, or even taking a count, but it's about getting the "W".
for the record, I also believe Pacquiao is faster than Khan and Mayweather isn't much slower, but the key is that Mayweather is much more accurate in attack and his reactions in defence are second to none.

[IamInuit]

Anybody would think that Mayweather was slow the way they bang on about Khan's speed. If Khan doesn't fight Mayweather or Brook who does he fight? Brook would be to Strong for Khan, and Khan's name shouldn't even be mentioned in same breath as Mayweather! They're calling out Mayweather because Khan is one more defeat away from oblivion! Let Khan fight Broner. That way at least one myth will be dispelled.

For reasons I have yet to figure out he is still relevant and a fairly good draw. Probably gets Floyd more cash then pretty much any other opponent. The reasons again for this I have no answer for. He's a fast good looking kid who hits pretty hard for a rake. His problem is upstairs. He's a boxer with the brains of a brawler and does not have the punch resistance to back that mentality up. He's got focus and game plan issues just like Judah did. In fact his career kind of looks the same. Not sure how he has come close to earning a shot but such is boxing.

Brook can now challenge Alexander again. Execute the mandatory or start paying rent. Time to shit or get off the pot. Should he win he can then take Khan in an all British punch up. It would probably sell out the 02. I'm not sold on Brook. I think he's a little paranoid of the elite. My gut feeling is that he's unsure of his chin.

Khan has no shot at Floyd or Broner. He'd look like a deer in the headlights against both of them. The first couple of rounds might look like we were about to see something special and then the power goes out.

[Kirkland Laing]

I think Khan is finished at world level. He was garbage last time out at 143 against a journeyman career lightweight. He got wobbled a couple of times in that fight. His chin isn't going to stand up to anybody at welter who can punch. I'd even back Alexander to stop him.

I read Khan might be fighting Guerrero next if he doesn't get Floyd. Guerrero would absolutely ruin him. I'm still not sold on Brook but if they ever do meet then Brook will spark him.

[smashup]

Plenty of fighters get caught with decent shots and just soak it up , Amir hasn't got that in him and fight by fight its getting worse.
I said already punch resistance wise he's shot.
Look back at some of the beatings he's taken ;-)
Khan has got a massive heart and no matter what state he's in he always gets up and wants to fight on.
Always been his downfall but he is pure entertainment.
His only chance against Brook is early on .