There is a difference between looking in shape, being in shape, being well defined, and having the strength and conditioning at a certain weight.
Basillio had a great physique. Meaning he was well defined and had conditioning to a certain degree. But when we compare him to a today's MW- from Hopkins, to RJJ, to GGG to even Ward and Dirrell, he would not last because he would be fighting unusually stronger and conditioned athletes.
It's not the same....
Bookmarks