Is Mayweather a all time great?

[beenKOed]

Of course Floyd is an ATG.

Where you rank him will depend on him still having that ZERO when he retires. Will be on the ATG list somewhere, regardless.

[El Kabong]

Of course Floyd is an ATG.

Where you rank him will depend on him still having that ZERO when he retires. Will be on the ATG list somewhere, regardless.

Does it? I think his legacy is fairly set right now given the opponents he has to choose from...now if he said "I'm going to grab a middleweight belt" and did so before he retired, then YES I would immediately put him up with SRR, Duran, Pep, Armstrong, and whoever else you can name. Other than that I don't even really see a loss hampering his career because he's already past his best but he's still great enough to school damn near anyone.