That sounds very familiar. We had 2 undecided and 1 guilty, the guy who thought the accused was guilty thought he was the bollocks, he didnt really get how you reach a verdict. When it comes down to it all feeling is taken out of it by the route to verdict, a simple set of questions, if at any point during the set of questions you have doubt thats game over, you dont have to like it but thast the way it is.