Floyd's competition vs Manny's competition

[ruthless rocco]

Oscar is a first ballot HOF inductee. Floyd moved up to fight him at his natural fighting weight and he beat him before Manny did. Manny fought ODL at a weight Oscar hadn't fought at in 8 years. Some accomplishment.

Gatti is also in the HOF. This is a fact. Mayweather dismantled him in 5 rounds.

JMM is certainly a future HOFmer.
Mosely is a future HOFmer.

Canelo may also be a future HOFmer.

If Floyd were allowed to hold titles in three weight divisions at once he probably would but that's prohibited now. He has held titles in two weight divisions at the same time but has always been forced to give one up.

[mikeeod]

Oscar is a first ballot HOF inductee. Floyd moved up to fight him at his natural fighting weight and he beat him before Manny did. Manny fought ODL at a weight Oscar hadn't fought at in 8 years. Some accomplishment. I haven't seen anyone but you list Oscar as one of Manny's biggest wins. There are numerous wins much more impressive like Cotto, Hatton, Morales, Bradley, JMM, Barerra, Ledwaba...etc. stick with those.

Gatti is also in the HOF. This is a fact. Mayweather dismantled him in 5 rounds. Gatti is in the HOF for the excitement he generated, not his boxing pedigree. Gatti was a tough guy and good man, but the fact that you put him on as a big win for PBF shows how much you have to reach. Angel Manfredy beat a more prime version of Gatti, as did Mickey Ward. Should they be HOF too?

JMM is certainly a future HOFmer.
Mosely is a future HOFmer.

Canelo may also be a future HOFer. Based off of what? What has Canelo done to even merit uttering the words HOF with his name? You are delusional.

If Floyd were allowed to hold titles in three weight divisions at once he probably would but that's prohibited now. He has held titles in two weight divisions at the same time but has always been forced to give one up.

Manny has faced tougher comp. I'm interested to see who he picks after Algieri as I know it will be a big fight.

[Silkeyjoe]

Oscar is a first ballot HOF inductee. Floyd moved up to fight him at his natural fighting weight and he beat him before Manny did. Manny fought ODL at a weight Oscar hadn't fought at in 8 years. Some accomplishment.

Gatti is also in the HOF. This is a fact. Mayweather dismantled him in 5 rounds.

JMM is certainly a future HOFmer.
Mosely is a future HOFmer.

Canelo may also be a future HOFmer.

If Floyd were allowed to hold titles in three weight divisions at once he probably would but that's prohibited now. He has held titles in two weight divisions at the same time but has always been forced to give one up.

Als if he was allowed defend tem against whoever he wants he probably would. Pesky mandatories