LOL

Surely you can't be serious! Some of them guys were never even champs!

They were not even HW's by todays standards.

Not a single one of them would survive a modern CW fight.

But I suppose, as @greynotsoold points out, you can only judge a fighter's greatness by the criteria of his era...

So going by that measuring stick, as an example.........

What the HELL is a full blown bum like James Braddock doing on ANY toplist, no matter what the criteria?

The fact that a guy like this can BECOME a champ is a PROOF of how poor a quality the era was.

I think if your gonna rank boxers on "greatness" the minimal criteria should atleast be that the boxer should not have a bum record.

Marciano went unbeaten in one of the weakest eras in history (because of the war), but atleast he had a clean record. Braddock has no excuse and no place on such a list.