Roy wasn't chinny in my opinion. He took a decent left hook from Toney in their fight n wasn't even buzzed. Tarver laded the perfect shot, at the perfect time n was a big puncher. I admire Roy for getting up from that one. He took a pounding from Johnson prior to being stopped. It's not like Glenn turned his lights out with his first solid shot...

I do think that Tarvers style would have always given aroy problems. Liles n Nunn were avoided for this reason, and Harding gave him fits because of his long build n southpaw jab. Griffins defense gave aroy fits in the first fight also. That being said, Roy wouldn't have been stopped by them for being chinny, he could take a decent shot until he list it mentally...