Yes it's silly for those reasons. I was sort of thinking if he had moved up to 200 instead of HW in 2003 to fight Ruiz, he would have beaten whatever version of Haye, who I think was overall a better fighter at HW incidentally. What was Hayes best performance at 200, Mormeck? I feel like he was a lot less durable himself at the weight, Roy would have still been able to hurt him or at the very least keep him honest.