Frampton Quigg scoring.

[erics44]

there were a couple of rounds quigg didn't through a punch

can that be a 10 - 8?

[Primo Carnera]

there were a couple of rounds quigg didn't through a punch

can that be a 10 - 8?

The way I see it, without knocks downs , for it to be a 10-8 round, you have to be completely dominant and landing some telling blows. That was never the case.
You could also ask if the Work Frampton did in those rounds warranted 10 points?
Can you win rounds by landing 5 or 10 jabs , even if you are busy and hitting arms with the rest?

[erics44]

there were a couple of rounds quigg didn't through a punch

can that be a 10 - 8?

The way I see it, without knocks downs , for it to be a 10-8 round, you have to be completely dominant and landing some telling blows. That was never the case.
You could also ask if the Work Frampton did in those rounds warranted 10 points?
Can you win rounds by landing 5 or 10 jabs , even if you are busy and hitting arms with the rest?

I personally think that even though Frampton was landing as few punches as quigg in the first six it was Frampton who was trying to land punches and make a fight of it so he deserved the rounds

if quigg had have come out with the same attitude as Frampton then we would have had a fight, instead it was very dull for 6 rounds

think of all the money spend by the public to watch the fight, rounds were scored to the fighter trying to engage, and rightly so

[erics44]

there were times where quigg would land a punch and then jump a 3 or 4 feet back, well out of range for both fighters, there was never any intention to follow anything up

it was clear his tactic was to come on later on, and to give him his dues he tried from round 8 onwards, which cant have been easy with a broken jaw

[Primo Carnera]

there were a couple of rounds quigg didn't through a punch

can that be a 10 - 8?

The way I see it, without knocks downs , for it to be a 10-8 round, you have to be completely dominant and landing some telling blows. That was never the case.
You could also ask if the Work Frampton did in those rounds warranted 10 points?
Can you win rounds by landing 5 or 10 jabs , even if you are busy and hitting arms with the rest?

I personally think that even though Frampton was landing as few punches as quigg in the first six it was Frampton who was trying to land punches and make a fight of it so he deserved the rounds

if quigg had have come out with the same attitude as Frampton then we would have had a fight, instead it was very dull for 6 rounds

think of all the money spend by the public to watch the fight, rounds were scored to the fighter trying to engage, and rightly so

It's a fair comment and I know that most people agree with you. I can accept people giving the rounds 10-9 to Frampton because he had the more positive attitude, but no way 10-8.
I accept Quigg was too negative , but imagine how he felt hearing he's 6 rounds down and he's hardly been hit because everything has been blocked by his gloves. (having said that , he got his jaw broke !)
I acknowledge that Frampton was the deserved winner.

[erics44]

I wanted quigg to win by the way, so there's absolutely no bias in my opinion

[Primo Carnera]

I know, and I think you make very fair points. I didn't mind Frampton winning, I quite like him, (Although if he tries to fight Selby at the weight above, he will get seriously embarrassed).

[erics44]

I know, and I think you make very fair points. I didn't mind Frampton winning, I quite like him, (Although if he tries to fight Selby at the weight above, he will get seriously embarrassed).

another pay per view?

I booked the fight late and ended up paying £20

I saw most of the McDonnell fight before it which was a mismatch and then the main even

I didnt get my value for money

[Fenster]

To have a 10-8 round, without a knockdown, you need to really batter your opponent. Frampton didn't even really dominate the early rounds, he was winning them by default.

[erics44]

I reckon there were 2 rounds where quigg didn't throw a punch

There should be something in the rules saying you need to throw at least 1 punch in a round otherwise its a 10-8 round

if there isn't already

[Fenster]

There's no way there was a round where Quigg literally didn't throw a punch.

[Fenster]

Awful tactics. Bet he's kicking himself today



Frampton-Quigg: CompuBox Breaks Down Their Punch Stats - Boxing News

[IamInuit]

I reckon there were 2 rounds where quigg didn't throw a punch

There should be something in the rules saying you need to throw at least 1 punch in a round otherwise its a 10-8 round

if there isn't already

There is no such rule but even if there was you cant call a 10/8 because Quigg threw nothing and Carl threw 2.

If not for the little flare up in spots over the last 5, this fight would have rivaled Wlad/Fury in lack of output.

[Dia bando]

This fight did not deliver the goods did it ! very poor very disappointing hell I am SO GLAD I never got any
tickets, nether fighter wanted to commit 4 rounds of some action for all the talk a fight devoid of action more of a sparring session, Shit what a let down.