Great perspective Iam.
That's why I tried to ask it two fold: Great fighter weak era/ average fighter great era.
The one problem all sports fans run into is trying to compare eras.
The one argument I hear when comparing IMO is subjective. When a fan visualizes an old era fighter in today's era......without flipping the script.
No PPV, not even closed circuit television
So a brittle hand Floyd Mayweather Jr. is forced to fight bimonthly, if not weekly.
In the 1950s...would he have had that Hispanic wise old man to start rapping his hands?
And with his safety first style...how would Ring magazine word it...after all, that was how fans across America learned of fight results...hard to get good fights If Ring magazine doesn't tout it.
I could envision Floyd as good yesterday as he is today, but due to the frequency in which he would be forced to fight, I can see his hands giving up on him.
As his only drop was a standing 8...a pain pierced his hand..his glove scraped the canvas ...and there starts his only count.
Floyd Mayweather Jr 1950-1968I'd say 95-4-2 losses on points ...out pointed by a windmill swinging Hank Armstrong, Split decision loss to SRR whose one handed power drops Floyd, but doesn't stop him.
A few draws because his defence saves him from his infrequent activity.
Floyd wouldn't shine as bright in yesteryear, not because of the talent, but he'd c get wore down trying to make ends meat.
Of course...it's just my opinion.![]()
Bookmarks