Where do you rank Terrence Crawford P4P?

[Ron Swanson]

Probably #5 after kovalev, ward, GGG, and chocolatito. But he could definitely have a case for being higher.

How are GGG and Kovalev above Crawford? Crawford has proven he is the best in 2 weight classes. While we assume GGG and Kovalev are the best in their 1 weight class each neither has proven it by beating the tops guys. And Ward, well, he proved it years ago but he hasn't done anything since. To me Kovalev/Ward are fighting for their spot later this year. Chocolatito is number 1 for sure.

I was thinking exactly the same. After they fight, one of them is going to be top 3, and one will go down quite a bit. Crawford is definitely top 5 , maybe top 3 , and I believe he could end up no.1 .
Now I'm not a fan of p4p rankings as there are so many subjectives and it's pretty meaningless. But one thing I would say is if Brook were to beat GGG (extremely unlikely I know.), then IMO he jumps from top 10-15 to no.1!

I wouldn't know what the hell to do with Brook if he pulled that off. Honestly I hadn't even considered it because I don't think he stands a chance. But I will say it would be hard to move him past Chocolatito for me. Anyone moving past Chocolatito would be hard for me. That dude is legit.

[Primo Carnera]

Probably #5 after kovalev, ward, GGG, and chocolatito. But he could definitely have a case for being higher.

How are GGG and Kovalev above Crawford? Crawford has proven he is the best in 2 weight classes. While we assume GGG and Kovalev are the best in their 1 weight class each neither has proven it by beating the tops guys. And Ward, well, he proved it years ago but he hasn't done anything since. To me Kovalev/Ward are fighting for their spot later this year. Chocolatito is number 1 for sure.

I was thinking exactly the same. After they fight, one of them is going to be top 3, and one will go down quite a bit. Crawford is definitely top 5 , maybe top 3 , and I believe he could end up no.1 .
Now I'm not a fan of p4p rankings as there are so many subjectives and it's pretty meaningless. But one thing I would say is if Brook were to beat GGG (extremely unlikely I know.), then IMO he jumps from top 10-15 to no.1!

I wouldn't know what the hell to do with Brook if he pulled that off. Honestly I hadn't even considered it because I don't think he stands a chance. But I will say it would be hard to move him past Chocolatito for me. Anyone moving past Chocolatito would be hard for me. That dude is legit.

Agree with that because Chocolatito has done it at multiple weights for a long time and I don't think anyone should jump above him, so in hindsight he could only go to no.2.
and for the record, I really don't think Brook can win (although I think he'll be more of a challenge for GGG than people think.) and the reason I said he jumps to the top , is because beating a guy who is one of the more dominant Champions at over a stone above your weight would be a ridiculous feat.
as a comparison, we both know if GGG went directly up in his next fight to challenge Kovalev with no CW's and beat him, rightly or wrongly people would be putting him at the top of the tree.
I really don't see the point of p4p rankings , but going back on the original post, Crawford is up there and I can only see his p4p position improving.

[Master]

How did Ward maintain his place? He has not been active and is at a new weight fighting poor fighters.