Vasyl Lomachenko is P4P #1

[Batman]

Hows about if we look at it as though for a one off fight then Brook would put on a good show against all of those listed, as he did with GGG, and he may even beat some of the named fighters.

However if he was to campaign full time at middleweight then the size difference and power of the bigger fighters would soon tell on his body and he would end up being broken down and having his career shortened?

Hows that sound lads? meet in the middle or something??

[Master]

Hows about if we look at it as though for a one off fight then Brook would put on a good show against all of those listed, as he did with GGG, and he may even beat some of the named fighters.

However if he was to campaign full time at middleweight then the size difference and power of the bigger fighters would soon tell on his body and he would end up being broken down and having his career shortened?

Hows that sound lads? meet in the middle or something??

No, he would not win and i want an apology and an acceptance that i was right, otherwise I will keep on posting everyday.

[Alpha]

Hows about if we look at it as though for a one off fight then Brook would put on a good show against all of those listed, as he did with GGG, and he may even beat some of the named fighters.

However if he was to campaign full time at middleweight then the size difference and power of the bigger fighters would soon tell on his body and he would end up being broken down and having his career shortened?

Hows that sound lads? meet in the middle or something??

No, he would not win and i want an apology and an acceptance that i was right, otherwise I will keep on posting everyday.

How do you think Brook (who fought GGG) does against those middleweights you mentioned at the time GGG fought them?

Geale: lost his second fight after GGG to Cotto who started at 140. Quit again.

Rubio: fought the early part of his career at 154. Losing to guys like Jantuah & Ouma. His best win at 160 is an inexperienced Lemieux.

Wade: what he really done? I thought he lost to Soliman.

Monroe: again his record is pretty lacking. Doesn't have a big punch but has some decent skills.

Murray: this would probably be the toughest test of the guys you listed.

You think all those guys beat the Brook that fought GGG?

[Master]

Hows about if we look at it as though for a one off fight then Brook would put on a good show against all of those listed, as he did with GGG, and he may even beat some of the named fighters.

However if he was to campaign full time at middleweight then the size difference and power of the bigger fighters would soon tell on his body and he would end up being broken down and having his career shortened?

Hows that sound lads? meet in the middle or something??

No, he would not win and i want an apology and an acceptance that i was right, otherwise I will keep on posting everyday.

How do you think Brook (who fought GGG) does against those middleweights you mentioned at the time GGG fought them?

Geale: lost his second fight after GGG to Cotto who started at 140. Quit again.

Rubio: fought the early part of his career at 154. Losing to guys like Jantuah & Ouma. His best win at 160 is an inexperienced Lemieux.

Wade: what he really done? I thought he lost to Soliman.

Monroe: again his record is pretty lacking. Doesn't have a big punch but has some decent skills.

Murray: this would probably be the toughest test of the guys you listed.

You think all those guys beat the Brook that fought GGG?

I think only Geale gets beaten because he was shot by that time the others beat Kell.

[Alpha]

I think Brook could beat them all.

[palmerq]

Hows about if we look at it as though for a one off fight then Brook would put on a good show against all of those listed, as he did with GGG, and he may even beat some of the named fighters.

However if he was to campaign full time at middleweight then the size difference and power of the bigger fighters would soon tell on his body and he would end up being broken down and having his career shortened?

Hows that sound lads? meet in the middle or something??

No, he would not win and i want an apology and an acceptance that i was right, otherwise I will keep on posting everyday.

How do you think Brook (who fought GGG) does against those middleweights you mentioned at the time GGG fought them?

Geale: lost his second fight after GGG to Cotto who started at 140. Quit again.

Rubio: fought the early part of his career at 154. Losing to guys like Jantuah & Ouma. His best win at 160 is an inexperienced Lemieux.

Wade: what he really done? I thought he lost to Soliman.

Monroe: again his record is pretty lacking. Doesn't have a big punch but has some decent skills.

Murray: this would probably be the toughest test of the guys you listed.

You think all those guys beat the Brook that fought GGG?

I think only Geale gets beaten because he was shot by that time the others beat Kell.

wade looked awful v golovkin, havent seen anything else of him though but he looked really really bad, almost as bad as prince charles martin S: I would think Brook would beat him.

[Alpha]

Hows about if we look at it as though for a one off fight then Brook would put on a good show against all of those listed, as he did with GGG, and he may even beat some of the named fighters.

However if he was to campaign full time at middleweight then the size difference and power of the bigger fighters would soon tell on his body and he would end up being broken down and having his career shortened?

Hows that sound lads? meet in the middle or something??

No, he would not win and i want an apology and an acceptance that i was right, otherwise I will keep on posting everyday.

How do you think Brook (who fought GGG) does against those middleweights you mentioned at the time GGG fought them?

Geale: lost his second fight after GGG to Cotto who started at 140. Quit again.

Rubio: fought the early part of his career at 154. Losing to guys like Jantuah & Ouma. His best win at 160 is an inexperienced Lemieux.

Wade: what he really done? I thought he lost to Soliman.

Monroe: again his record is pretty lacking. Doesn't have a big punch but has some decent skills.

Murray: this would probably be the toughest test of the guys you listed.

You think all those guys beat the Brook that fought GGG?

I think only Geale gets beaten because he was shot by that time the others beat Kell.

wade looked awful v golovkin, havent seen anything else of him though but he looked really really bad, almost as bad as prince charles martin S: I would think Brook would beat him.

Agreed and I think Brook would be able to handle Rubio. Monroe is a decent boxer but I think Kell is more than capable of beating him also.

[Master]

Hows about if we look at it as though for a one off fight then Brook would put on a good show against all of those listed, as he did with GGG, and he may even beat some of the named fighters.

However if he was to campaign full time at middleweight then the size difference and power of the bigger fighters would soon tell on his body and he would end up being broken down and having his career shortened?

Hows that sound lads? meet in the middle or something??

No, he would not win and i want an apology and an acceptance that i was right, otherwise I will keep on posting everyday.

How do you think Brook (who fought GGG) does against those middleweights you mentioned at the time GGG fought them?

Geale: lost his second fight after GGG to Cotto who started at 140. Quit again.

Rubio: fought the early part of his career at 154. Losing to guys like Jantuah & Ouma. His best win at 160 is an inexperienced Lemieux.

Wade: what he really done? I thought he lost to Soliman.

Monroe: again his record is pretty lacking. Doesn't have a big punch but has some decent skills.

Murray: this would probably be the toughest test of the guys you listed.

You think all those guys beat the Brook that fought GGG?

I think only Geale gets beaten because he was shot by that time the others beat Kell.

wade looked awful v golovkin, havent seen anything else of him though but he looked really really bad, almost as bad as prince charles martin S: I would think Brook would beat him.

Agreed and I think Brook would be able to handle Rubio. Monroe is a decent boxer but I think Kell is more than capable of beating him also.

Rubio lost to Jantuah and Ouma when they were at the top of their game at light middle.

Regardless of what you think I am sure GGG would not say Brook was one of his best wins of his career, which is how this whole debate started. It was a scheduled fight and easy money.

[Gandalf]

Hows about if we look at it as though for a one off fight then Brook would put on a good show against all of those listed, as he did with GGG, and he may even beat some of the named fighters.

However if he was to campaign full time at middleweight then the size difference and power of the bigger fighters would soon tell on his body and he would end up being broken down and having his career shortened?

Hows that sound lads? meet in the middle or something??

No, he would not win and i want an apology and an acceptance that i was right, otherwise I will keep on posting everyday.

It should be a written apology, with a signature, seal, and a dollop of lipstick kiss to provide no doubt as to who the sender is.

[TitoFan]

Hows about if we look at it as though for a one off fight then Brook would put on a good show against all of those listed, as he did with GGG, and he may even beat some of the named fighters.

However if he was to campaign full time at middleweight then the size difference and power of the bigger fighters would soon tell on his body and he would end up being broken down and having his career shortened?

Hows that sound lads? meet in the middle or something??

No, he would not win and i want an apology and an acceptance that i was right, otherwise I will keep on posting everyday.

It should be a written apology, with a signature, seal, and a dollop of lipstick kiss to provide no doubt as to who the sender is.

There should be crying involved as well.

[Gandalf]

Hows about if we look at it as though for a one off fight then Brook would put on a good show against all of those listed, as he did with GGG, and he may even beat some of the named fighters.

However if he was to campaign full time at middleweight then the size difference and power of the bigger fighters would soon tell on his body and he would end up being broken down and having his career shortened?

Hows that sound lads? meet in the middle or something??

No, he would not win and i want an apology and an acceptance that i was right, otherwise I will keep on posting everyday.

It should be a written apology, with a signature, seal, and a dollop of lipstick kiss to provide no doubt as to who the sender is.

There should be crying involved as well.

Blood stained tears dropped in a delicate pattern across the letter are a welcome sign of sincerity.

[imp]

Winner of Ward vs Kov 2 is the P4P best.

Early days yet for Lomachenko.

[TitoFan]

But before his career was shortened.... he'd go back to 147 for one last fight, and the opponent would be Khan, who would be claiming that Brook had moved to 160 to duck him. Then Brook would KO him in the 1st round and promptly retire.

The End

[Master]

But before his career was shortened.... he'd go back to 147 for one last fight, and the opponent would be Khan, who would be claiming that Brook had moved to 160 to duck him. Then Brook would KO him in the 1st round and promptly retire.

The End

Or he gets ko by Spence. The end.

[TitoFan]

If I was Khan I'd be ticked off about all the attention Brook is getting here about his jump to MW.

Khan did exactly the same thing, only against Canelo... and got KTFO'ed.

But he might be saying, "Hey, how 'bout me??" "I could give some of them middles a fight for their money."



Only in boxing....

Brook and Khan should've fought each other eons ago, yet they both chose ill-advised jumps to MW to get their respective asses handed to them.