P4p goat.

[Alpha]

James Toney.

Consistent.

I'm going to say Robinson, but I wouldn't argue with anyone that said Armstrong or Ali.

[Spicoli]

Read and experienced after the fact..Robinson. Benny Leonard never gets his due in early era.

Lived live..Whitaker or Lopez if I'm honest. Certainly limits choices.

experiencing a fighter recorded and live are very different.

[Dean Duke]

Jack Johnson past

Sugar Ray Leonard now

[X]

​Achilles

[Boxer4life]

Pound for Pound . I think Mike Tyson takes Sugar Ray. So if we're talking about actually fighting and not statistics I think its a toss up between Ali and Tyson.

[powerpuncher]

James Toney.

Consistent.

I'm going to say Robinson, but I wouldn't argue with anyone that said Armstrong or Ali.

I have pep above Armstrong. Pep is unbelievable. But I wouldn’t necessarily argue either way. Again, maybe I’m bias.

[mikeeod]

How are we defining great? If it is best inside the ring, Armstrong with Robinson as a close second. If we are talking global impact and impact outside the ropes, then I go with Ali and Joe Louis and Jack Johnson as close second and third.