Rankings?

[Alpha]

Was thinking of getting a feel for what the forum's rankings were each month.

We could all post our current top 5 (minimum of 3, only top 5 will be counted) in each division (or the divisions you want) and we could rank the top 3 in each class based on the results.

So I'll leave voting open until next Friday (then I'll post the results), so you can place your middleweight fights (GGG/Canelo, Gonzalez etc) after the weekend.

Can I just ask that if you make a new post instead of editing, makes it easier to keep track of.

I'll start:

Anthony Joshua
Deontay Wilder
Alexander Povetkin
Tyson Fury
Dillian Whyte

Oleksandr Usyk
Mairis Briedis
Murat Gassiev
Krzysztof Glowacki
Yunier Dorticos

Eleider Alvarez
Adonis Stevenson
Artur Beterbiev
Oleksandr Gvozdyk
Dmitry Bivol

George Groves
Gilberto Ramirez
David Benavidez
James DeGale
Jose Uzcategui

Jarrett Hurd
Jermell Charlo
Erislandy Lara
Jamie Munguia
Brian Carlos Castano

Errol Spence Jr
Terence Crawford
Shawn Porter
Danny Garcia
Manny Pacquiao

Mikey Garcia
Vasyl Lomachenko
Jorge Linares
Robert Easter Jr
Jose Pedraza

Miguel Berchelt
Alberto Machado
Gervonta Davis
Francisco Vargas
Miguel Roman

Gary Russell Jr.
Leo Santa Cruz
Carl Frampton
Josh Warrington
Oscar Valdez

Isaac Dogboe
Rey Vargas
Daniel Roman
Jessie Magdaleno
TJ Doheny

Ryan Burnett
Naoya Inoue
Zolani Tete
Rau'shee Warren
Juan Carlos Payano


Artem Dalakian
Moruti Mthalane
Andrew Selby
Cristofer Rosales
Sho Kimura

Ken Shiro
Hekkie Budler
Ryoichi Taguchi
Milan Melindo
Carlos Canizales

Thammanoon Niyomtrong
Chayaphon Moonsri
Hiroto Kyoguchi
Simphiwe Khonco
Vic Saludar

I'll post my 160, 140 and 115 after the weekend.

Hopefully we get a good response, so we can get a decent representation of the forum.

[TitoFan]

Good thread. I'll start at 118, and add as I go along.


Naoya Inoue
Emmanuel Rodriguez
Ryan Burnett
Zolani Tete
Juan Carlos Payano

[TitoFan]

Heavies:

Anthony Joshua
Deontay Wilder
Alexander Povetkin
Dillian Whyte
Luis Ortiz

[TitoFan]

Welter:

Crawford
Spence
Porter
Garcia
Pacquiao

[powerpuncher]

Good idea. I’ll get mine in sometime

[TitoFan]

108 pounds:

Angel Acosta
Hekkie Budler
Milan Melindo
Carlos Canizales
Ryoichi Taguchi

[TitoFan]

130 pounds:

Gervonta Davis
Alberto Machado
Miguel Berchelt
Masayuki Ito
Christopher Diaz

[powerpuncher]

I’m assuming these rankings are just our personal preference who we think is best? Like how we rank p4p. There doesn’t have to be any sort of reasoning beyond I think one fighter is better than another despite record, level of opposition, etc.

[powerpuncher]

HW
Wilder
AJ
Ortiz
Whyte
Miller

LHW
Bivol
Gvozdyk
Beterbiev
Alvarez
Kovalev

Super middleweight
Ramirez
Groves
Benavidez
Uzgategui
Degale

Welterweight
Crawford
Spence
Porter
Garcia
Pacquiao

Lightweight
Garcia
Loma
Easter
Linares
Pedraza

Super featherweight
Berchelt
Davis
Machado
Roman
Rakhimov

Featherweight
Santa Cruz
Russell
Frampton
Warrington

I do some more later

[Master]

Where is Adonis Stevenson in your list?

[powerpuncher]

Where is Adonis Stevenson in your list?

I don’t think he’s top 5

[Spicoli]

Good stuff. We used to have a voting for ratings thread but need to get current.

Hvy

Joshua..Wilder..Povetkin..Ortiz..Whyte


147

Spence..Crawford..Porter..Garcia..Pacquiao


135

Garcia..Loma..Linares..Commey..Pedraza

[Alpha]

I’m assuming these rankings are just our personal preference who we think is best? Like how we rank p4p. There doesn’t have to be any sort of reasoning beyond I think one fighter is better than another despite record, level of opposition, etc.

Yea basically how you rate your top 3-5 in each division.

If others want to debate your rankings, they are free to, might gets some good debate and possibly some agreement.

[Alpha]

Where is Adonis Stevenson in your list?

I don’t think he’s top 5

Good call with Rakhimov at 130


My 140:
Regis Prograis
Josh Taylor
Kiryl Relikh
Jose Carlos Ramirez
Viktor Postol

[powerpuncher]

I can do middleweight now. And since this is still opinion and we don’t have to care about judges scoring, I don’t have to have Canelo at the top.

GGG
Charlo
Saunders
Jacobs
Canelo