Rankings?

[Alpha]

I can do middleweight now. And since this is still opinion and we don’t have to care about judges scoring, I don’t have to have Canelo at the top.

GGG
Charlo
Saunders
Jacobs
Canelo

Ditto for me, @Alpha

Saves me from typing anything at all.

Thanks guys, some divisions are getting a clear #1 so far, others are very tight. The more votes we can get will help give a better representation of the forums rankings.

[Master]

Canelo
GGG
Jacobs
Saunders
Charlo

As you have to respect the f@cking judges decision.

[Ron Swanson]

Respect all your opinions but I will abstain because to me there are too many unanswered questions in boxing right now.

For example I think Charlo might be the best MW in the world, or he might be number 7

[powerpuncher]

Respect all your opinions but I will abstain because to me there are too many unanswered questions in boxing right now.

For example I think Charlo might be the best MW in the world, or he might be number 7

Agreed. But it’s like p4p. You never really know but it’s all just fun speculation

[powerpuncher]

Canelo
GGG
Jacobs
Saunders
Charlo

As you have to respect the f@cking judges decision.

I think the point of this is to say who YOU rank despite judges

[TitoFan]

Canelo
GGG
Jacobs
Saunders
Charlo

As you have to respect the f@cking judges decision.

I think the point of this is to say who YOU rank despite judges

I'd have to agree, @Master

At least that's how I looked at it. The judges decision means nothing to me. I thought GGG won both fights. No way i'm putting him below Canelo on my personal list.

[Master]

Canelo
GGG
Jacobs
Saunders
Charlo

As you have to respect the f@cking judges decision.

I think the point of this is to say who YOU rank despite judges

I'd have to agree, @Master

At least that's how I looked at it. The judges decision means nothing to me. I thought GGG won both fights. No way i'm putting him below Canelo on my personal list.

Then some people may have Jacobs top and that seems wrong.

[TitoFan]

Canelo
GGG
Jacobs
Saunders
Charlo

As you have to respect the f@cking judges decision.

I think the point of this is to say who YOU rank despite judges

I'd have to agree, @Master

At least that's how I looked at it. The judges decision means nothing to me. I thought GGG won both fights. No way i'm putting him below Canelo on my personal list.

Then some people may have Jacobs top and that seems wrong.

If they feel Jacobs should've gotten the nod over GGG then so be it. It's our own personal choices and opinions. Canelo lost TWICE to GGG only to have decisions taken away from him. Canelo's lucky to make the top 5 with me.

[Alpha]

Respect all your opinions but I will abstain because to me there are too many unanswered questions in boxing right now.

For example I think Charlo might be the best MW in the world, or he might be number 7

All good Ron, would love to have your rankings on any of the divisions if you want, the more votes, the more spread the rankings will be, and helps break any ties. A top 3 is minimum. However you currently rank them.

Canelo
GGG
Jacobs
Saunders
Charlo

As you have to respect the f@cking judges decision.

I think the point of this is to say who YOU rank despite judges

I'd have to agree, @Master

At least that's how I looked at it. The judges decision means nothing to me. I thought GGG won both fights. No way i'm putting him below Canelo on my personal list.

Then some people may have Jacobs top and that seems wrong.

If they feel Jacobs should've gotten the nod over GGG then so be it. It's our own personal choices and opinions. Canelo lost TWICE to GGG only to have decisions taken away from him. Canelo's lucky to make the top 5 with me.

Yea depends on how you rank guys. I think me and Master follow the official decisions when ranking in division, more so than P4P.