Rankings?

[TitoFan]

Canelo
GGG
Jacobs
Saunders
Charlo

As you have to respect the f@cking judges decision.

I think the point of this is to say who YOU rank despite judges

I'd have to agree, @Master

At least that's how I looked at it. The judges decision means nothing to me. I thought GGG won both fights. No way i'm putting him below Canelo on my personal list.

Then some people may have Jacobs top and that seems wrong.

If they feel Jacobs should've gotten the nod over GGG then so be it. It's our own personal choices and opinions. Canelo lost TWICE to GGG only to have decisions taken away from him. Canelo's lucky to make the top 5 with me.

[Alpha]

Respect all your opinions but I will abstain because to me there are too many unanswered questions in boxing right now.

For example I think Charlo might be the best MW in the world, or he might be number 7

All good Ron, would love to have your rankings on any of the divisions if you want, the more votes, the more spread the rankings will be, and helps break any ties. A top 3 is minimum. However you currently rank them.

Canelo
GGG
Jacobs
Saunders
Charlo

As you have to respect the f@cking judges decision.

I think the point of this is to say who YOU rank despite judges

I'd have to agree, @Master

At least that's how I looked at it. The judges decision means nothing to me. I thought GGG won both fights. No way i'm putting him below Canelo on my personal list.

Then some people may have Jacobs top and that seems wrong.

If they feel Jacobs should've gotten the nod over GGG then so be it. It's our own personal choices and opinions. Canelo lost TWICE to GGG only to have decisions taken away from him. Canelo's lucky to make the top 5 with me.

Yea depends on how you rank guys. I think me and Master follow the official decisions when ranking in division, more so than P4P.

[powerpuncher]

Respect all your opinions but I will abstain because to me there are too many unanswered questions in boxing right now.

For example I think Charlo might be the best MW in the world, or he might be number 7

All good Ron, would love to have your rankings on any of the divisions if you want, the more votes, the more spread the rankings will be, and helps break any ties. A top 3 is minimum. However you currently rank them.

Canelo
GGG
Jacobs
Saunders
Charlo

As you have to respect the f@cking judges decision.

I think the point of this is to say who YOU rank despite judges

I'd have to agree, @Master

At least that's how I looked at it. The judges decision means nothing to me. I thought GGG won both fights. No way i'm putting him below Canelo on my personal list.

Then some people may have Jacobs top and that seems wrong.

If they feel Jacobs should've gotten the nod over GGG then so be it. It's our own personal choices and opinions. Canelo lost TWICE to GGG only to have decisions taken away from him. Canelo's lucky to make the top 5 with me.

Yea depends on how you rank guys. I think me and Master follow the official decisions when ranking in division, more so than P4P.

I think in “official” rankings you have to have the outcome count. With these rankings, I’m just going off of who I think is the best despite what I consider bad scoring. For example, when Bradley “beat” Pacquiao, I wouldn’t rank Bradley higher in the division because he obviously wasn’t better. The judges were just blind.

[Alpha]

115:
Wangek
Estrada
Gonzalez
Ioka
Ancajas


Would love more votes on heavy, light-heavy, super-middle, welter, feather from anyone who hasn't already voted on these weights.

[palmerq]

I'll try the ones I can remember.. Probably won't make a perfect list as I don't watch absolutely everything.


Hw
Joshua
Whyte
Wilder
Fury tyson
Povetkin

Cruiserweight.

Usyk
Breidis
Glowacki

Lhw.
Bivol
The russian geezer nicknamed the nail, I forget his name
Kovalev(he's still good but I may be well wrong with this one)
Buatsi


Smw
Groves
Smith
Ramirez

Middleweight
Alvarez
Golovkin
Saunders
Jacobs

154
Hurd
Lara munguia
I've actually not seen the Charlo fellows in action yet :S

147
Crawford(i think he is a controlled evil force in a great frame, what a guy)
The third earl of Spence..
Pacman(he's still got something left).
Porter
Thurmam


Now I'm forgetting who is at what weight now :S....

Whatever weight lomachenko is

1. Lomachenko.
2. M garcia (I think they are around the same weight).
3.Gervonta davis
.


The hbo super flyweight cards(I think inoue moved up)

Sor rungvisai
Estrada
Roman Gonzalez (hard to say with him he looked like he was really getting back into the swing of things but his opponent was busy planning on becoming an uber driver).
Ioka
Not sure on past that, could have nietes or palcite or mcwilliams arroyo or kal yafai....


The rest I'm really not qualified enough to rate properly... I would say inoue is king of whatever weight class he's in now(these halflings move weight so quickly sometimes). Everytime I've seem he looks to be a monster

[Alpha]

I'll try the ones I can remember.. Probably won't make a perfect list as I don't watch absolutely everything.


Hw
Joshua
Whyte
Wilder
Fury tyson
Povetkin

Cruiserweight.

Usyk
Breidis
Glowacki

Lhw.
Bivol
The russian geezer nicknamed the nail, I forget his name
Kovalev(he's still good but I may be well wrong with this one)
Buatsi


Smw
Groves
Smith
Ramirez

Middleweight
Alvarez
Golovkin
Saunders
Jacobs

154
Hurd
Lara munguia
I've actually not seen the Charlo fellows in action yet :S

147
Crawford(i think he is a controlled evil force in a great frame, what a guy)
The third earl of Spence..
Pacman(he's still got something left).
Porter
Thurmam


Now I'm forgetting who is at what weight now :S....

Whatever weight lomachenko is

1. Lomachenko.
2. M garcia (I think they are around the same weight).
3.Gervonta davis
.


The hbo super flyweight cards(I think inoue moved up)

Sor rungvisai
Estrada
Roman Gonzalez (hard to say with him he looked like he was really getting back into the swing of things but his opponent was busy planning on becoming an uber driver).
Ioka
Not sure on past that, could have nietes or palcite or mcwilliams arroyo or kal yafai....


The rest I'm really not qualified enough to rate properly... I would say inoue is king of whatever weight class he's in now(these halflings move weight so quickly sometimes). Everytime I've seem he looks to be a monster

Awesome mate, thanks so much for taking the time to reply.

OK so Loma and Garcia are at Lightweight. Davis is at 130. So if you can give me 1 more lightweight (3 is the minimum for accepted votes) and have a look at 130 I can add these on.

Inoue is at bantam, if you could give me 2 more bantams I can add these as well.

[palmerq]

I'll try the ones I can remember.. Probably won't make a perfect list as I don't watch absolutely everything.


Hw
Joshua
Whyte
Wilder
Fury tyson
Povetkin

Cruiserweight.

Usyk
Breidis
Glowacki

Lhw.
Bivol
The russian geezer nicknamed the nail, I forget his name
Kovalev(he's still good but I may be well wrong with this one)
Buatsi


Smw
Groves
Smith
Ramirez

Middleweight
Alvarez
Golovkin
Saunders
Jacobs

154
Hurd
Lara munguia
I've actually not seen the Charlo fellows in action yet :S

147
Crawford(i think he is a controlled evil force in a great frame, what a guy)
The third earl of Spence..
Pacman(he's still got something left).
Porter
Thurmam


Now I'm forgetting who is at what weight now :S....

Whatever weight lomachenko is

1. Lomachenko.
2. M garcia (I think they are around the same weight).
3.Gervonta davis
.


The hbo super flyweight cards(I think inoue moved up)

Sor rungvisai
Estrada
Roman Gonzalez (hard to say with him he looked like he was really getting back into the swing of things but his opponent was busy planning on becoming an uber driver).
Ioka
Not sure on past that, could have nietes or palcite or mcwilliams arroyo or kal yafai....


The rest I'm really not qualified enough to rate properly... I would say inoue is king of whatever weight class he's in now(these halflings move weight so quickly sometimes). Everytime I've seem he looks to be a monster

Awesome mate, thanks so much for taking the time to reply.

OK so Loma and Garcia are at Lightweight. Davis is at 130. So if you can give me 1 more lightweight (3 is the minimum for accepted votes) and have a look at 130 I can add these on.

Inoue is at bantam, if you could give me 2 more bantams I can add these as well.

OK will do,

Had to look up boxrec to see who is where.


135
Lomachenko
Garcia
Linares

130
Davis
Berchelt
Vargas

Inoue weight

Inoue
Inoue
Inoue:S
Tete
Cuadras(on his day he can be tip top, might be a bad ranking otherwise)....

I mean nagoya inoue times 3 and not his brother.. want to emphasize how great inoue has looked so far.


I have excluded Rigondeuax as I don't know if he is still going and it really looked like lomachenko beat a lot out of him.

[Alpha]

I'll try the ones I can remember.. Probably won't make a perfect list as I don't watch absolutely everything.

Lhw.
Bivol
The russian geezer nicknamed the nail, I forget his name
Kovalev(he's still good but I may be well wrong with this one)
Buatsi

Kov was recently knocked out by Eleider Alvarez.

[palmerq]

I'll try the ones I can remember.. Probably won't make a perfect list as I don't watch absolutely everything.

Lhw.
Bivol
The russian geezer nicknamed the nail, I forget his name
Kovalev(he's still good but I may be well wrong with this one)
Buatsi

Kov was recently knocked out by Eleider Alvarez.

Yes I know but I think he got his conditioning wrong and he's going to come back hard. I don't rate Colombian Canadian alvarez too much. So I'm sticking with Kovalev 3rd

[Fenster]

Would love more votes on heavy, light-heavy, super-middle, welter, feather from anyone who hasn't already voted on these weights.

I am specifically picking my best 5 fighters per division. For example - i've eliminated faded old boys with justifiable formlines to rank high - Kovalev, Stevenson and Degale for young guys who I think would beat them.

Heavyweight

1. AJ
2. Povetkin
3. Wilder
4. Whyte
5. Fury

light-heavy

1. Eleider Alvarez
2. Dmitry Bivol
3. Artur Beterbiev
4. Oleksandr Gvozdyk
5. Badou Jack

super-middle

1. George Groves
2. David Benavidez
3. Callum Smith
4. Jose Uzcategui
5. Chris Eubank Jr

welter

1. Errol Spence Jr
2. Terence Crawford
3. Keith Thurman
4. Shaun Porter
5. Danny Garcia

feather

1. Carl Frampton
2. Leo Santa Cruz
3. Oscar Valdez
4. Gary Russell Jr.
5. Genesis Servania

[powerpuncher]

Would love more votes on heavy, light-heavy, super-middle, welter, feather from anyone who hasn't already voted on these weights.

I am specifically picking my best 5 fighters per division. For example - i've eliminated faded old boys with justifiable formlines to rank high - Kovalev, Stevenson and Degale for young guys who I think would beat them.

Heavyweight

1. AJ
2. Povetkin
3. Wilder
4. Whyte
5. Fury

light-heavy

1. Eleider Alvarez
2. Dmitry Bivol
3. Artur Beterbiev
4. Oleksandr Gvozdyk
5. Badou Jack

super-middle

1. George Groves
2. David Benavidez
3. Callum Smith
4. Jose Uzcategui
5. Chris Eubank Jr

welter

1. Errol Spence Jr
2. Terence Crawford
3. Keith Thurman
4. Shaun Porter
5. Danny Garcia

feather

1. Carl Frampton
2. Leo Santa Cruz
3. Oscar Valdez
4. Gary Russell Jr.
5. Genesis Servania

Two interesting things. First, no Ramirez at super middle? And second, Thurman is still in your rankings?

[powerpuncher]

I’m just not super impressed by Alvarez at LHW. He did beat Kovalev fair and square, but I didn’t think he looked that impressive in previous fights and was definitely losing the fight before he landed his big shot. I think he loses to the other Russians and Ukrainians in the division

[Fenster]

Would love more votes on heavy, light-heavy, super-middle, welter, feather from anyone who hasn't already voted on these weights.

I am specifically picking my best 5 fighters per division. For example - i've eliminated faded old boys with justifiable formlines to rank high - Kovalev, Stevenson and Degale for young guys who I think would beat them.

Heavyweight

1. AJ
2. Povetkin
3. Wilder
4. Whyte
5. Fury

light-heavy

1. Eleider Alvarez
2. Dmitry Bivol
3. Artur Beterbiev
4. Oleksandr Gvozdyk
5. Badou Jack

super-middle

1. George Groves
2. David Benavidez
3. Callum Smith
4. Jose Uzcategui
5. Chris Eubank Jr

welter

1. Errol Spence Jr
2. Terence Crawford
3. Keith Thurman
4. Shaun Porter
5. Danny Garcia

feather

1. Carl Frampton
2. Leo Santa Cruz
3. Oscar Valdez
4. Gary Russell Jr.
5. Genesis Servania

Two interesting things. First, no Ramirez at super middle? And second, Thurman is still in your rankings?

Well Thurman will be back soon and barring Spence and Crawford I'd pick him over Pac, who would have been in my five.

I don't think much of Ramirez, I purposely put Eubank Jr no.5 because I think stylistically he would batter him.

Remember I was picking my five best per division not who deserves a high ranking.