Should transgenered people be allowed to box?

[Gandalf]

I will fight any of you at a CW of 125 pounds which is the weight I will need to go to minus my penis.

You can keep it and weigh over at 125.03 to be fair. I’ll stick to cutting my right leg off and go with a bone marrow extraction. No shark costumes though, that way I wouldn’t know if you’ve had hormone replacement to try and grow a pair of balls or not.

When the council puts up a sign saying 'No ball games' are they trying to tell us something? I think all this gender lark is going way too far.

[p4pking]

I don’t know much about councils, aside from that clearly wasn’t the reason you fled yours for Korea .

[X]

​So, would Buffalo Bill beat Serena Williams over ten rounds then?

[TitoFan]

​So, would Buffalo Bill beat Serena Williams over ten rounds then?

Serena?? She would beat Buffalo Bill into submission and then break him in half with a deathly leg grip.

[Andre]

​So, would Buffalo Bill beat Serena Williams over ten rounds then?

10 rounds of whiskey or pints sure.

[TitoFan]

Well..... I don't know about women's boxing.... but there sure are a lot of women athletes coming forward now on transgender sports in general.


https://www.dailywire.com/news/45336...nst-frank-camp

"Another Female Athletic Champion Comes Out Against Male-To-Female Transgender Participation In Women’s Sports"



Damn. Paula Radcliffe must not have gotten the memo that by expressing those thoughts, it now makes her "transphobic."

Oh well... it's only the voice of one retired long-distance runner, right? Good thing she didn't post that on Saddo's. She'd be burned at the stake.

Oh but wait...


https://www.pinknews.co.uk/2019/03/3...sgender-women/

"Gabby Logan says transgender women competing in sport is ‘not fair’"


That is the surprisingly uncritical article headline on Pink News, a UK-based online newspaper marketed toward the LGBTQ community.

Gabby is another former woman athlete weighing in on the subject.

There's probably more, right?


https://www.theguardian.com/society/...ender-athletes

"Sports stars weigh in on row over transgender athletes"


So you've got Paula Radcliffe, Gabby Logan, Martina Navratilova, Kelly Holmes, Sharron Davies, and a host of other women athletes speaking out against transgender male-to-females in females sports. And they're not even talking exclusively about women's boxing, where the object of the sport is to beat each other senseless.

Good thing they weren't in here arguing with the likes of Beanz. Or maybe he knows what's best over and above all these women athletes who actually participate in women sports.

But never mind that. Here's the most telling excerpt from the last article which basically puts it all in a nutshell........



"But Fair Play for Women insists women are clearly disadvantaged at both elite and grassroots level when they compete against trans athletes.

“Claims of transphobia are wild and unfounded,” its spokeswoman Dr Nicola Williams told the Guardian. “It is a tool used to shame women into silence. We want to get past not being able to speak out and to encourage a debate that leads to sports bodies implementing policies that are fair to women."


Claims of transphobia are a TOOL USED TO SHAME WOMEN INTO SILENCE. How about that. Did you hear that Beanz? Because when I said it, you pooh-poohed it like you do everything that doesn't agree with your own dirty little agenda. Now that actual women athletes are saying it, maybe it'll bore a hole in your skull and stay there.


News flash, sport: It's entirely possible that some of those women boxers who claim not to have a problem fighting transgenders are AFRAID OF BEING SHAMED INTO SILENCE. So they go with the flow and secretly hope not to get their heads bashed in by a Mike Tyson turned girly.


I know nobody here likes to hear about this subject, but I just thought I'd nail the coffin shut on this one.

[walrus]

Well..... I don't know about women's boxing.... but there sure are a lot of women athletes coming forward now on transgender sports in general.


https://www.dailywire.com/news/45336...nst-frank-camp

"Another Female Athletic Champion Comes Out Against Male-To-Female Transgender Participation In Women’s Sports"



Damn. Paula Radcliffe must not have gotten the memo that by expressing those thoughts, it now makes her "transphobic."

Oh well... it's only the voice of one retired long-distance runner, right? Good thing she didn't post that on Saddo's. She'd be burned at the stake.

Oh but wait...


https://www.pinknews.co.uk/2019/03/3...sgender-women/

"Gabby Logan says transgender women competing in sport is ‘not fair’"


That is the surprisingly uncritical article headline on Pink News, a UK-based online newspaper marketed toward the LGBTQ community.

Gabby is another former woman athlete weighing in on the subject.

There's probably more, right?


https://www.theguardian.com/society/...ender-athletes

"Sports stars weigh in on row over transgender athletes"


So you've got Paula Radcliffe, Gabby Logan, Martina Navratilova, Kelly Holmes, Sharron Davies, and a host of other women athletes speaking out against transgender male-to-females in females sports. And they're not even talking exclusively about women's boxing, where the object of the sport is to beat each other senseless.

Good thing they weren't in here arguing with the likes of Beanz. Or maybe he knows what's best over and above all these women athletes who actually participate in women sports.

But never mind that. Here's the most telling excerpt from the last article which basically puts it all in a nutshell........



"But Fair Play for Women insists women are clearly disadvantaged at both elite and grassroots level when they compete against trans athletes.

“Claims of transphobia are wild and unfounded,” its spokeswoman Dr Nicola Williams told the Guardian. “It is a tool used to shame women into silence. We want to get past not being able to speak out and to encourage a debate that leads to sports bodies implementing policies that are fair to women."


Claims of transphobia are a TOOL USED TO SHAME WOMEN INTO SILENCE. How about that. Did you hear that Beanz? Because when I said it, you pooh-poohed it like you do everything that doesn't agree with your own dirty little agenda. Now that actual women athletes are saying it, maybe it'll bore a hole in your skull and stay there.


News flash, sport: It's entirely possible that some of those women boxers who claim not to have a problem fighting transgenders are AFRAID OF BEING SHAMED INTO SILENCE. So they go with the flow and secretly hope not to get their heads bashed in by a Mike Tyson turned girly.


I know nobody here likes to hear about this subject, but I just thought I'd nail the coffin shut on this one.

They are professional athletes what do they know. This is an outrage to the LBGTBP people

[TitoFan]

Well..... I don't know about women's boxing.... but there sure are a lot of women athletes coming forward now on transgender sports in general.


https://www.dailywire.com/news/45336...nst-frank-camp

"Another Female Athletic Champion Comes Out Against Male-To-Female Transgender Participation In Women’s Sports"



Damn. Paula Radcliffe must not have gotten the memo that by expressing those thoughts, it now makes her "transphobic."

Oh well... it's only the voice of one retired long-distance runner, right? Good thing she didn't post that on Saddo's. She'd be burned at the stake.

Oh but wait...


https://www.pinknews.co.uk/2019/03/3...sgender-women/

"Gabby Logan says transgender women competing in sport is ‘not fair’"


That is the surprisingly uncritical article headline on Pink News, a UK-based online newspaper marketed toward the LGBTQ community.

Gabby is another former woman athlete weighing in on the subject.

There's probably more, right?


https://www.theguardian.com/society/...ender-athletes

"Sports stars weigh in on row over transgender athletes"


So you've got Paula Radcliffe, Gabby Logan, Martina Navratilova, Kelly Holmes, Sharron Davies, and a host of other women athletes speaking out against transgender male-to-females in females sports. And they're not even talking exclusively about women's boxing, where the object of the sport is to beat each other senseless.

Good thing they weren't in here arguing with the likes of Beanz. Or maybe he knows what's best over and above all these women athletes who actually participate in women sports.

But never mind that. Here's the most telling excerpt from the last article which basically puts it all in a nutshell........



"But Fair Play for Women insists women are clearly disadvantaged at both elite and grassroots level when they compete against trans athletes.

“Claims of transphobia are wild and unfounded,” its spokeswoman Dr Nicola Williams told the Guardian. “It is a tool used to shame women into silence. We want to get past not being able to speak out and to encourage a debate that leads to sports bodies implementing policies that are fair to women."


Claims of transphobia are a TOOL USED TO SHAME WOMEN INTO SILENCE. How about that. Did you hear that Beanz? Because when I said it, you pooh-poohed it like you do everything that doesn't agree with your own dirty little agenda. Now that actual women athletes are saying it, maybe it'll bore a hole in your skull and stay there.


News flash, sport: It's entirely possible that some of those women boxers who claim not to have a problem fighting transgenders are AFRAID OF BEING SHAMED INTO SILENCE. So they go with the flow and secretly hope not to get their heads bashed in by a Mike Tyson turned girly.


I know nobody here likes to hear about this subject, but I just thought I'd nail the coffin shut on this one.

They are professional athletes what do they know. This is an outrage to the LBGTBP people

You missed the Q and the XYZ.

[Beanz]

Well..... I don't know about women's boxing.... but there sure are a lot of women athletes coming forward now on transgender sports in general.


https://www.dailywire.com/news/45336...nst-frank-camp

"Another Female Athletic Champion Comes Out Against Male-To-Female Transgender Participation In Women’s Sports"



Damn. Paula Radcliffe must not have gotten the memo that by expressing those thoughts, it now makes her "transphobic."

Oh well... it's only the voice of one retired long-distance runner, right? Good thing she didn't post that on Saddo's. She'd be burned at the stake.

Oh but wait...


https://www.pinknews.co.uk/2019/03/3...sgender-women/

"Gabby Logan says transgender women competing in sport is ‘not fair’"


That is the surprisingly uncritical article headline on Pink News, a UK-based online newspaper marketed toward the LGBTQ community.

Gabby is another former woman athlete weighing in on the subject.

There's probably more, right?


https://www.theguardian.com/society/...ender-athletes

"Sports stars weigh in on row over transgender athletes"


So you've got Paula Radcliffe, Gabby Logan, Martina Navratilova, Kelly Holmes, Sharron Davies, and a host of other women athletes speaking out against transgender male-to-females in females sports. And they're not even talking exclusively about women's boxing, where the object of the sport is to beat each other senseless.

Good thing they weren't in here arguing with the likes of Beanz. Or maybe he knows what's best over and above all these women athletes who actually participate in women sports.

But never mind that. Here's the most telling excerpt from the last article which basically puts it all in a nutshell........



"But Fair Play for Women insists women are clearly disadvantaged at both elite and grassroots level when they compete against trans athletes.

“Claims of transphobia are wild and unfounded,” its spokeswoman Dr Nicola Williams told the Guardian. “It is a tool used to shame women into silence. We want to get past not being able to speak out and to encourage a debate that leads to sports bodies implementing policies that are fair to women."


Claims of transphobia are a TOOL USED TO SHAME WOMEN INTO SILENCE. How about that. Did you hear that Beanz? Because when I said it, you pooh-poohed it like you do everything that doesn't agree with your own dirty little agenda. Now that actual women athletes are saying it, maybe it'll bore a hole in your skull and stay there.


News flash, sport: It's entirely possible that some of those women boxers who claim not to have a problem fighting transgenders are AFRAID OF BEING SHAMED INTO SILENCE. So they go with the flow and secretly hope not to get their heads bashed in by a Mike Tyson turned girly.


I know nobody here likes to hear about this subject, but I just thought I'd nail the coffin shut on this one.

The only women shamed into silence in this thread were the female boxers who were quite happy to fight trans people. You pretended they didn't exist and just quoted fighters that agreed with you.

'Dirty little Agenda' "bore a hole in your skull' 'burned at the stake'?

Go back and read and you will see you are just inventing stuff. More than aware of the whole debate and those athletes I expect you have never heard of. Master reffered to it right at the start. Been all over the British media. Great program on Radio 4, I will look up for you about it from weeks ago.

Interesting fact. I once kissed Plymouth legend Sharon Davies. I was 11 and I got to shake Superstars and Judo champ Brian Jack's hand too.

[Master]

I loved Superstars and Brian Jack's was a hero of mines!

Remember kevin keegan crashing on his bike!

[TitoFan]

The only women shamed into silence in this thread were the female boxers who were quite happy to fight trans people. You pretended they didn't exist and just quoted fighters that agreed with you.

'Dirty little Agenda' "bore a hole in your skull' 'burned at the stake'?

Go back and read and you will see you are just inventing stuff. More than aware of the whole debate and those athletes I expect you have never heard of. Master reffered to it right at the start. Been all over the British media. Great program on Radio 4, I will look up for you about it from weeks ago.

Interesting fact. I once kissed Plymouth legend Sharon Davies. I was 11 and I got to shake Superstars and Judo champ Brian Jack's hand too.

Oh c'mon Beanz. You're desperately grasping at straws in a shameful way, just for the sake of trying not to lose an argument. "The only women shamed into silence in this thread were the female boxers who were quite happy to fight trans people"??

Do you even read what you shovel?

Those women aren't reading this thread, Beanz..... not that I should have to clear that up for you.

Those women are quite happy harping on about how they would gladly fight trans people. Probably because #1 they know full well they probably won't really have to face any..... and #2 probably they don't want to sound like wimps. It's a win-win situation. You say the right thing.... and can privately refuse later on if the situation were to come up.

And yet you fail to understand how women objectors are the ones being shamed into silence? Really?....................... Really?

Do you understand that it's not just me saying it.... it's women authority figures in sports? Including athletes?

Is "winning" an argument worth more to you than the safety of women in sports? (Nod your head yes). Go ahead... admit it. Everyone's entitled to their opinion no matter how wrong and disgusting.



BTW, many of these women objectors are talking about sprinting, football, cycling...... sports other than boxing where again the objective is to knock each other senseless.

Logic would say it's even more of an issue in boxing, where permanent damage and injury can occur.



Amazing how you clutch onto your "house of cards" argument.