
Originally Posted by
TIC

Originally Posted by
TitoFan
That is the only thing that matters at this point. Wild conjectures about the cause are pointless and frankly only damaging at this point. But that doesn't stop people from doing it.
The NFL has its hands full right now, as it desperately tries to balance the sensitivity of Hamlin's injuries with the remainder of the season and the looming playoffs.
I'd hate to be in those front offices (NFL) during these times. They're bound to get criticized no matter what they decide.
just because people are questioning the cause does not mean they are not concern for this man. master posted a question
asking if we are seeing more of these incidents as he must be noticing something that he felt like asking the forum. i agree wild conjectures are pointless. the question from master & my own about other possibilities of cause are far from wild conjectures & are more about reasoned discussion. you & i will never know the real cause, no matter what the media says but i for one will be keeping an eye out hoping that these incidents don't become more regular. i'm not really familiar with the workings of the nfl, could you please inform me what you are referencing there? in regards to the remainder of the season & being in the front offices. from their point of view wasn't this tragic incident just a random occurrence off a routine tackle? or are they getting flack about player safety of something? what decision are they supposed to make?
It doesn't appear we are
"seeing more of these incidents." But here's a look back at other cardiac related incidents on the field of play (including other sports):
https://www.insider.com/sports-stars...-hamlin-2023-1
"Damar Hamlin isn't the first pro athlete to have cardiac arrest on the field — here are 5 other stars who collapsed while the clock was running"
From the article:
- Chuck Hughes, Detroit Lions NFL player - Collapsed without contact on the field of play in 1971 and died
- Christian Eriksen, Danish soccer player - Non-contact collapse during Euro 2020 during a game in 2021. Was revived.
- Chris Pronger, NHL St. Louis Blues - Collapsed after hit from puck on chest during game in 1998. Made a full recovery.
- Jay Bouwmeester, NHL St. Louis Blues - Collapsed while on bench in 2020. Was revived and later retired from the sport.
- Marc-Vivien Foé, Cameroon soccer team - Non-contact collapse during game in 2003. Could not be revived.
Also from the article:
"Buffalo Bills player Damar Hamlin has been hospitalized in critical condition after being treated on the field for cardiac arrest. The 24-year-old safety collapsed after a tackle during a Monday night game against the Bengals.
While the details of Hamlin's health aren't yet clear, the incident is part of a long history of athletes suffering cardiac events during competition in sports, such as football, soccer, and hockey.
Dozen of other such incidents have occurred in the past few decades, some of them fatal. While heart problems in elite athletes are rare, they can occur because of underlying conditions, including undiagnosed heart disease or genetic abnormalities, which are exacerbated by intense exercise and physical stress, according to research published in 2019.
Getting hit in the chest with enough force can also disrupt the heartbeat, a condition called commotio cordis, which is also rare but can be caused by an object like a hockey puck or baseball, or contact with another player.
While pro athletes are routinely screened for medical conditions, some risks are difficult to predict or prevent, resulting in shocking and occasionally deadly mid-game medical emergencies."
"Underlying conditions"... "undiagnosed heart disease"... "genetic abnormalities". "Exacerbated by intense exercise and physical stress..."
I'm going with these for the time being.
Factually-based opinions from medical professionals, whose opinions have more weight than anybody on Facebook or Twitter.
Oh... about the NFL and its decisions.
The game where Hamlin was injured was finally postponed after it was clear that none of the players were in any emotional shape to continue. The game was critical in determining playoff positioning and seeding for the beginning of playoff season a week and a half from now. The NFL has a decision to make as to whether make up this game... cancel it altogether... or push the playoffs back in order to accommodate the finishing of the game at some later date. Their decision will have ramifications on a group of teams currently fighting for playoff positioning.
The play itself where Hamlin was injured was most definitely a routine tackle, which obviously factors into the determinations being made as we speak as to the possible causes for the injury. Until more knowledgeable minds than you or I come to some sort of conclusions, the cause remains unknown. The league (NFL) meanwhile, finds itself in the unenviable position of having to delicately balance the still uncertain outcome of Hamlin's recovery, with the need to finish the season and begin the playoffs.
Bookmarks