
Originally Posted by
Kirkland Laing
If you're a female athlete you do not have the right not to compete against a trans athlete. Every week there is some event where trans athletes compete against female athletes. If such a right existed there'd be endless lawsuits from religious and other anti trans groups seeking injunctions and ruling the participation of trans athletes unconstitutional. What you do have is a bunch of recent laws passed in certain states that ban trans athletes from taking part in sports events. In this case it's the rights of trans athletes that have been taken away.
Wow. Ok. I guess we'll just have to agree to (vehemently) disagree.

Originally Posted by
Kirkland Laing
If you're a teacher or professor you do not have the right not to call students by their preferred pronouns. You can read about it here:
An Indiana school district did not violate a former music teacher's rights by pushing him to resign after the man refused to use transgender students' names and gender pronouns, a federal appeals court said in an order released Friday.
The decision from the 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld a prior ruling in the case by a federal judge.
https://www.nbcchicago.com/news/loca...nouns/3115061/
There have been various cases going the other way in state courts but this is the first federal ruling and it's one step below Supreme Court level. I don't think even this Supreme Court will waste its capital and credibility on this issue so this would appear to be the law of the land as far as federal laws apply in various states. There is certainly no right derived from the constitution for teachers to refuse to use whatever pronouns students prefer and that's from the second highest court in the land.
Whatever. You can quote all the laws you want. It doesn't make it right. All it does is prove what a fucked-up world we live in, where reality is being destroyed by the made-up fantasies of a deluded (but powerful) few.

Originally Posted by
Kirkland Laing
And you don't have a constitutional right to not have your kids taught whatever. Right now in the majority of the country kids are given some level of sex and gender at elementary school even though it boils the piss of millions of parents. Just they live in areas where the school boards support this being done. They have no right to prevent it as the law in pretty much every state is that local school boards decide the curriculum.
This short video will help you understand the difference between laws and rights and how they're applied an interpreted in your country:
Forget it. I don't need to watch a video to help me understand what's wrong and what's right. Laws are routinely drawn up to satisfy the people with the most pull in a society. Morals and values be damned.
You obviously have no kids... or you'd be a little more sympathetic to the need of parents to be able to raise their little tykes according to their own principles and morals.
If this is wrong and obscene to you... there's little more to talk about.

Originally Posted by
Kirkland Laing
As far as bullied kids go there are dozens of suicides every year by kids far too young to get any kind of gender treatments. As far as transgender people overall what you've done is mention that you've read a couple of stories about trans people who had treatment killing themselves. But the plural of anecdote is not data. The data is quite clear:
Stop for a second, Kirk. I'm not gonna go toe-to-toe with you on statistics you're going to skew anyway. There's hard evidence on the existence of transitioned suicides that don't come out in the news, because it doesn't fit the LGBTQXYZ Gestapo narrative. ALSO.... have you given a 2nd thought as to WHY these "bullied kids" that are far too young for gender treatment commit suicide?? No... I guess not. Could it possibly be because they weren't given the necessary counseling, love, and direction at home?? No... I guess not. Again... it doesn't fit the narrative.
Just to be clear, you haven't proven a DAMN thing throughout all these arguments. All you have are (passionate, vested, obviously personal-based) opinions. They're no better nor any accurate than mine.
Bookmarks