Yeah but the argument can be made that Nunn was not in his prime either, he was into heavy drugs leading into the Toney fight. But he was still top P4P so I think he can be considered great.

Anyways, like I said in another thread, not to many GREAT fighters get beat in their prime. Not many at all. Then to throw the southpaw factor in the mix, well it's damn near impossible to find a fighter who was 100% in his prime, no questions about it, who was beat clearly. By decision no less.