Quote Originally Posted by Tito_BHB
Thing is is too damn tough for his own good..

He keeps bieng denied of that heavyweight title and hasnt had that win to go out on top..

He was given a draw against Rahman when he won..

He robbed himself of the wba title against Ruiz..

The judges robbed him of the first sam peter fight so he didnt get the shot at rahman.. But was HELLA lucky to get the rematch with peter.. Of which he did alot better then everyone says he did but he DID loose .. In all fairness peter is a great fight, he looked great in that fight.. but if toney had of been given a just decision the first time .. then i have no doubt he would have beaten maskaev and at least retired having been the heavyweight champ should he have lost the title later
Yes, a decision over Peter and then a win over Maskaev was the ideal way for Toney to finish his career. Its awkward for me as a fan to see the way it has gone. None of us have seen how James really looked in this fight and having seen split decisions in fights I clearly saw going only one way (Floyd: Oscar....Taylor:Spinks) I wouldnt be too hasty to draw any conclusions on Toney yet.

Until I see this fight, I wont yet be calling for time on Toney's career....