Roy was amazing no doubt. On his night he may well have been thee best ever but....

His longevity was much less than other fighters on my list...
His Legacy does not contain near as many repauatable names as the guys iv included.
When he did fall from grace it was brutally by a KO and he was unable to avenge.
His career isn't done yet so i can't fully judge.

(That may sound as if it conflicts with my inclusion of PBF but Floyd has done enough already to make the list having ticked off names such as DLH, Castillo, Gatti, Corrales even Chavez.)