Joe Louis broke Max Schmeling's back on a foul?

**donnydarkoIRL** · 02-20-2008 09:21 AM

Well whilst it is true that Louis did throw a foul blow, it was due to Schmeling turning his side to a Louis hook. Schmeling had been hurt prior to the noited punch and it did not matter in that fight, he was going down in the first regardless.

**chazky** · 06-23-2011 07:16 PM

He turned? Nice try. You can spin any way you want. Fact is the punch hit Schmeling in the spine. It broke. Schmeling was hospitalized for two weeks after the fight. The turn is a theory that's been around for some time but there has no visual evidence to support it.

**marbleheadmaui** · 06-23-2011 08:42 PM

It wasn't a foul. At that time in the sport kidney punches, for example, were still legal.

I'm not sure why you think this information is a mystery though. It has been known and widely disseminatd in interviews, books etc. since the time of the fight. The most widely read magazine in the US at the time, Life Magazine, did a photo expose and discussion on this very issue right after the fight. The punch that broke Max's back has long been believed to be the source of Schmeling's scream.

**Master** · 06-29-2011 09:29 PM

Max Schmeling's did turn his back and Joe kept on punching as the ref had not stopped it. Did not realise that it caused that much damage. Then again I would have hated to be facing Joe then who was out for revenge and in the peak of conditions. A bit like facing Roy Jones after his disqualification against Montell Griffin. No one was going to deny them a victory.