1. Floyd Mayweather Jr.

2. Manny Pacquiao

3. Bernard Hopkins

4. Joe Calzaghe

5. Juan Manuel Marquez & Miguel Cotto

7. Israel Vasquez

8. Kelly Pavlik

9. Rafael Marquez

10. Ronald Wright

Look I have revised your list. You cannot have 11 fighters in a top ten list. Thats ludricous.
When 2 positions are tied, then yes you can have joint 5th, but next one becomes 7th.

Really what you should have done was in the event of a tie, see who had the most 1st place votes, if there were no first place votes, then who had most second places and carry on until they were seperated.