No matter who he beats, can calzaghe be the lbs4lbs greatest?

[Fenster]

TO regard Calzaghe as P4P no.1 would mean you believe he beats Floyd (and every other fighter in the world) in a mythical match-up with their size and weight leveled.

Calzaghe beating Hopkins, Pavlik and whoever else still doesn't mean he would beat Floyd should they meet in a fantasy scenario.. unless you choose to believe that of course

[eagle]

Calzaghe is a great fighter no doubt about it, but i find it hard to see him passing PBF unless Floyd loses.

For example. How is a win over a 40 odd yr old BHOP a better win for Joe C than a win for PBF over a mid 30's DLH?

PBF's next fight at 154 will be 24 pounds above the weight he was at when he first won a title, that'd be like Joe C fighting and winning at Cruiser against a top guy (He may well be able to do that.).

I think a win over BHOP may warrant Joe C being P4P 2 or 3, but he has to do something extraordinary to be number 1 whilst PBF is still winning.