No matter who he beats, can calzaghe be the lbs4lbs greatest?

[LondonBB]

The way your talking though is like Mayweather isn't going to be fighting when Calzaghe is fighting those names you said, if were playing that game then say Mayweather beats ODLH again, Cotto, and Williams or Mosley. Then will Calzaghe still be rated higher than Mayweather in your mind ??

Great point mate!

As you say, should mayweather beat say dlh, cotto and mosley then i WOULD rate him higher than joe c. It would be mayweather 1st and joe 2nd in my opinion.

What is this obsession with p4p though? The fact will remain at supermiddle and light heavy joe c will clean up, be undisputed champ of 2 divisions with opponents from everywhere in the world (should he be triumphant in the states).

Thats all that needs to be said...mayweathers achievements (should he keep winning) will probably be greater than joe's but in the end they are both easily the best at their partcular weights.

But...lets wait and see...maybe i am wrong and joe will lose, fairplay then i willingly conceed that joe is not top 3 p4p (but probably floating nearer the bottom of the top 10).

What a build up this is, gonna be an exciting line up of boxing for the next year i think...for us all to enjoy!!!

[Fenster]

P4P i'd back Calzaghe to beat Pac all day long.. and he's generally the 2 man, right?

So Calzaghe has a case for being P4P 2.. according to Fenster.

He's not though because i'd back Guzman to beat Calzaghe P4P (along with a good few other fighters) so I can't rate him in the 2 spot.

Get me?

[Dark Lord Al]

The way your talking though is like Mayweather isn't going to be fighting when Calzaghe is fighting those names you said, if were playing that game then say Mayweather beats ODLH again, Cotto, and Williams or Mosley. Then will Calzaghe still be rated higher than Mayweather in your mind ??

Great point mate!

As you say, should mayweather beat say dlh, cotto and mosley then i WOULD rate him higher than joe c. It would be mayweather 1st and joe 2nd in my opinion.

What is this obsession with p4p though? The fact will remain at supermiddle and light heavy joe c will clean up, be undisputed champ of 2 divisions with opponents from everywhere in the world (should he be triumphant in the states).

Thats all that needs to be said...mayweathers achievements (should he keep winning) will probably be greater than joe's but in the end they are both easily the best at their partcular weights.

But...lets wait and see...maybe i am wrong and joe will lose, fairplay then i willingly conceed that joe is not top 3 p4p (but probably floating nearer the bottom of the top 10).

What a build up this is, gonna be an exciting line up of boxing for the next year i think...for us all to enjoy!!!

Yes ifs and buts dont get you to number 1 p4p , and the Hopkins fight is not going to be a walk in the park for Calzaghe.
so as i said Calzaghe isnt even close to Mayweather or Pacman. HIS remume is a joke compared to those guys.