I percieve a big future problem with rep

[CutMeMick]

Bilbs, I hate to bother to go look but after how many Rep. Points do earn 1 punch point?

Do you know?

[CutMeMick]

Ok so I just checked and every 100 Reps. gives you 1 power point.

Maybe Saddo can change it to every 500 Reps. gives you 1 point?

[Kev]

Ok so I just checked and every 100 Reps. gives you 1 power point.

Maybe Saddo can change it to every 500 Reps. gives you 1 point?

That doesn't fix the problem though. The root of the problem is that we have punch stats which constantly inflate.

The only way to solve the problem is to go back to EVERYBODY having the same punch power!

Or say when someone reaches a milestone 5000 posts for example they get 1 more punchpower but its fixed for everyone when they hit 5000 to get that increase.

The current system is fundamentally flawed imo.

1 click per person is the best system imo.

[Kev]

Bilbs, I hate to bother to go look but after how many Rep. Points do earn 1 punch point?

Do you know?

Yep every 100 points.

So say in two weeks from now you and me will be able to add a whole rep point to anyone we click.

Even if we choose to limit the amount or rep we give per punch the problem is still there and will get bigger and bigger over time.

At the current rate by Christmas you and me will have punch power of AT LEAST 1000 per hit!

That would mean if we gave a full power hit, a brand new member could get full rep from say you, me, Gamo and Gorilla and ALREADY have a bigger reputation than Wacko!


The system sucks imo

[CutMeMick]

Well we can also all Rep. WackOff everyday so he doesn't fall off.

I just Raped FUCK!
I mean Repped him right now.

[Kev]

Well we can also all Rep. WackOff everyday so he doesn't fall off.

I just Raped FUCK!
I mean Repped him right now.

Yeah but that's a cumbersome thing to have to do. Means you have to search for old posts and realistically how many people would do that every day to make sure he doesn't fall behind.

I just think the system itself is flawed.

The coolclick system was much simpler and more importantly worked much better.

People gave both coolclicks and sadclicks, we had special smilies devoted to both, the anonyminty ensured people were free to click without fear of retribution or without looking like they were pandering for a coolclick themselves.

Nobody's reputation would get left behind just because they didn't log in for a few weeks and any reputation that anybody built was deserved.

If you had 2000 coolclicks under the old system, it mean you had been clicked 2000 times. No trickery, no illusion that was 2000 clicks.

Under this new system you could have a reputation of 2000 and been clicked less than 100 times, in another couple months you get that score by being clicked just 3 or 4 times

[CutMeMick]

Well we can also all Rep. WackOff everyday so he doesn't fall off.

I just Raped FUCK!
I mean Repped him right now.

Yeah but that's a cumbersome thing to have to do. Means you have to search for old posts and realistically how many people would do that every day to make sure he doesn't fall behind.

I just think the system itself is flawed.

The coolclick system was much simpler and more importantly worked much better.

People gave both coolclicks and sadclicks, we had special smilies devoted to both, the anonyminty ensured people were free to click without fear of retribution or without looking like they were pandering for a coolclick themselves.

Nobody's reputation would get left behind just because they didn't log in for a few weeks and any reputation that anybody built was deserved.

If you had 2000 coolclicks under the old system, it mean you had been clicked 2000 times. No trickery, no illusion that was 2000 clicks.

Under this new system you could have a reputation of 2000 and been clicked less than 100 times, in another couple months you get that score by being clicked just 3 or 4 times

I'd do that for my boy Wakcs...
Heres where you show how much people actually care for the guy...
Bunch of fucken brown noses who would only come around his Rd. by Rd. and say things like your great! your my boy! your this...

Where are they now?

Anyway.... I rarely Sad Clicked on the old forum once in a while I would go into OLD threads and Sad Click old members... I've Bad Repped a few people here...

[Kev]

Well we can also all Rep. WackOff everyday so he doesn't fall off.

I just Raped FUCK!
I mean Repped him right now.

Yeah but that's a cumbersome thing to have to do. Means you have to search for old posts and realistically how many people would do that every day to make sure he doesn't fall behind.

I just think the system itself is flawed.

The coolclick system was much simpler and more importantly worked much better.

People gave both coolclicks and sadclicks, we had special smilies devoted to both, the anonyminty ensured people were free to click without fear of retribution or without looking like they were pandering for a coolclick themselves.

Nobody's reputation would get left behind just because they didn't log in for a few weeks and any reputation that anybody built was deserved.

If you had 2000 coolclicks under the old system, it mean you had been clicked 2000 times. No trickery, no illusion that was 2000 clicks.

Under this new system you could have a reputation of 2000 and been clicked less than 100 times, in another couple months you get that score by being clicked just 3 or 4 times

I'd do that for my boy Wakcs...
Heres where you show how much people actually care for the guy...
Bunch of fucken brown noses who would only come around his Rd. by Rd. and say things like your great! your my boy! your this...

Where are they now?

Anyway.... I rarely Sad Clicked on the old forum once in a while I would go into OLD threads and Sad Click old members... I've Bad Repped a few people here...

It's not for us to have to do that though! Can't you not see that the system at present is a little broken.

It doesn't matter what tweak Saddo does sooner or later we will arrive at a point where the vast majority of users have a puncher power in the 1000's.

If you place a limit on punch power eventually EVERYBODY will just hit that maximum limit and we'll all have the same punch power.

Which really begs the question why not just do that now and set everyone's punch power back to 1?

Fair democracry in action.

[CutMeMick]

Yeah but that's a cumbersome thing to have to do. Means you have to search for old posts and realistically how many people would do that every day to make sure he doesn't fall behind.

I just think the system itself is flawed.

The coolclick system was much simpler and more importantly worked much better.

People gave both coolclicks and sadclicks, we had special smilies devoted to both, the anonyminty ensured people were free to click without fear of retribution or without looking like they were pandering for a coolclick themselves.

Nobody's reputation would get left behind just because they didn't log in for a few weeks and any reputation that anybody built was deserved.

If you had 2000 coolclicks under the old system, it mean you had been clicked 2000 times. No trickery, no illusion that was 2000 clicks.

Under this new system you could have a reputation of 2000 and been clicked less than 100 times, in another couple months you get that score by being clicked just 3 or 4 times

I'd do that for my boy Wakcs...
Heres where you show how much people actually care for the guy...
Bunch of fucken brown noses who would only come around his Rd. by Rd. and say things like your great! your my boy! your this...

Where are they now?

Anyway.... I rarely Sad Clicked on the old forum once in a while I would go into OLD threads and Sad Click old members... I've Bad Repped a few people here...

It's not for us to have to do that though! Can't you not see that the system at present is a little broken.

It doesn't matter what tweak Saddo does sooner or later we will arrive at a point where the vast majority of users have a puncher power in the 1000's.

If you place a limit on punch power eventually EVERYBODY will just hit that maximum limit and we'll all have the same punch power.

Which really begs the question why not just do that now and set everyone's punch power back to 1?

Fair democracry in action.

Set everyones punch power to 1?
WTF... Why?

[Douglas]

Bilbs, I hate to bother to go look but after how many Rep. Points do earn 1 punch point?

Do you know?

Yep every 100 points.

So say in two weeks from now you and me will be able to add a whole rep point to anyone we click.

Even if we choose to limit the amount or rep we give per punch the problem is still there and will get bigger and bigger over time.

At the current rate by Christmas you and me will have punch power of AT LEAST 1000 per hit!

That would mean if we gave a full power hit, a brand new member could get full rep from say you, me, Gamo and Gorilla and ALREADY have a bigger reputation than Wacko!


The system sucks imo

He could make it so that you're not allowed to recieve but so much rep at once until your rep count or punch power reaches a certain number. (That way a newbie couldn't come on here and get repped by a powerful poster like Mick and already have a high punch power. Only a poster like Wacko who deserved it could get it.)

[CutMeMick]

Bilbs, I hate to bother to go look but after how many Rep. Points do earn 1 punch point?

Do you know?

Yep every 100 points.

So say in two weeks from now you and me will be able to add a whole rep point to anyone we click.

Even if we choose to limit the amount or rep we give per punch the problem is still there and will get bigger and bigger over time.

At the current rate by Christmas you and me will have punch power of AT LEAST 1000 per hit!

That would mean if we gave a full power hit, a brand new member could get full rep from say you, me, Gamo and Gorilla and ALREADY have a bigger reputation than Wacko!


The system sucks imo

He could make it so that you're not allowed to recieve but so much rep at once until your rep count or punch power reaches a certain number. (That way a newbie couldn't come on here and get repped by a powerful poster like Mick and already have a high punch power. Only a poster like Wacko who deserved it could get it.)

That makes sense...
So if I can't click them that means that can't earn any punching power and only those with a small number can Rep. thus leaving me to Rep. members like Wacko, Bilbo, BG etc. etc.
So if I Rep. them their power will increase but not rapidly which means we would all somewhat be the same and.......

(I have know fucken idea, what I just typed )

[Kev]

Yep every 100 points.

So say in two weeks from now you and me will be able to add a whole rep point to anyone we click.

Even if we choose to limit the amount or rep we give per punch the problem is still there and will get bigger and bigger over time.

At the current rate by Christmas you and me will have punch power of AT LEAST 1000 per hit!

That would mean if we gave a full power hit, a brand new member could get full rep from say you, me, Gamo and Gorilla and ALREADY have a bigger reputation than Wacko!


The system sucks imo

He could make it so that you're not allowed to recieve but so much rep at once until your rep count or punch power reaches a certain number. (That way a newbie couldn't come on here and get repped by a powerful poster like Mick and already have a high punch power. Only a poster like Wacko who deserved it could get it.)

That makes sense...
So if I can't click them that means that can't earn any punching power and only those with a small number can Rep. thus leaving me to Rep. members like Wacko, Bilbo, BG etc. etc.
So if I Rep. them their power will increase but not rapidly which means we would all somewhat be the same and.......

(I have know fucken idea, what I just typed )

I'm repeating what I just said but it applies here as well........


But all of these things take time and complicate the system.

Why not just go back to the old coolclick sadclick system where there were no problems to begin with

And also your idea would just widen the gap between a high rep poster and a newbie.

Why not just have 1 click for everybody, its democratic.

[CutMeMick]

He could make it so that you're not allowed to recieve but so much rep at once until your rep count or punch power reaches a certain number. (That way a newbie couldn't come on here and get repped by a powerful poster like Mick and already have a high punch power. Only a poster like Wacko who deserved it could get it.)

That makes sense...
So if I can't click them that means that can't earn any punching power and only those with a small number can Rep. thus leaving me to Rep. members like Wacko, Bilbo, BG etc. etc.
So if I Rep. them their power will increase but not rapidly which means we would all somewhat be the same and.......

(I have know fucken idea, what I just typed )

I'm repeating what I just said but it applies here as well........


But all of these things take time and complicate the system.

Why not just go back to the old coolclick sadclick system where there were no problems to begin with

And also your idea would just widen the gap between a high rep poster and a newbie.

Why not just have 1 click for everybody, its democratic.

Don't yopu remember all those threads?
Who Sad Clicked me?
Whos Sad Clicking me?
I hate not knowing who Sad Clicked me....

[Douglas]

Yep every 100 points.

So say in two weeks from now you and me will be able to add a whole rep point to anyone we click.

Even if we choose to limit the amount or rep we give per punch the problem is still there and will get bigger and bigger over time.

At the current rate by Christmas you and me will have punch power of AT LEAST 1000 per hit!

That would mean if we gave a full power hit, a brand new member could get full rep from say you, me, Gamo and Gorilla and ALREADY have a bigger reputation than Wacko!


The system sucks imo

He could make it so that you're not allowed to recieve but so much rep at once until your rep count or punch power reaches a certain number. (That way a newbie couldn't come on here and get repped by a powerful poster like Mick and already have a high punch power. Only a poster like Wacko who deserved it could get it.)

That makes sense...
So if I can't click them that means that can't earn any punching power and only those with a small number can Rep. thus leaving me to Rep. members like Wacko, Bilbo, BG etc. etc.
So if I Rep. them their power will increase but not rapidly which means we would all somewhat be the same and.......

(I have know fucken idea, what I just typed )

In other words, a new member you might could only give 10 reps, but if he had a certain rep count, it might extend to 20, and so on.......


..... What am I talkin' about now?

[Saddo]

OK i knew this was a fast building thing but that is because we see rep counts this system didn't have that i added it because when i changed the forum people where saying...

i had 1000 CC's and now i only have 10 power... WERE THE FUCKS MY CC's.

thus the reps count had to be shown.

this isnt the same format as the CC's and isnt ment to be if the reps get out of hand and people end up with 1000 punch power then i just get rid on the rep count and keep power numbers only as it should be... it would just be like someone having 1000 CC's

then just cap the reps that can be given to a max of 100. ((not sure i want to cap it yet))

this isnt an unfair system it works fine the problem is you guys are comparing it to CC/SC's it is not that..... it works on its own format and apart from the head start the old members got with there CC/SC ratio everyone started this system together at the same time and that is why new members have a high ratio.

then we have old members like Wacko who havnet been here for 2+ months and have missed out on this system... well to be totally honest there is fuck all i can do about that it is hard enough for me to keep the posters that are active happy for me to start worring about the ones who dont come on the board anymore.

but i'm sure if Wacko turned up everyone would rep him and build him up to what he was because that is what this place is all about

the CC's where only added to peoples reps here to stop them feeling that they had lost something.... in reality they had because reps are a total diffent system

BUT....

i plan on adding a thankyou points system to run along side the reps system where rather than giving reps for anything and everything you can just thank them for there post and it will be a one for one system.

thus making the reps a more valuble thing to give or take away and not something you give just because you got rep.

what you need to remember this place isnt an archive to old members it is a board for active members and if poster are on the missing from the board and not active then they wont give a shit what there ratings are because they are not here

Also...

i plan on making the rep points spendable so you can trade them for things that i will be inplanting to the forum over time.


....................

the CC/SC system is gone and i could prob tweak this system to resemble it but not enough to please all and to be honest this system is better for the long term plan of the board.

we just need to stop holding on to an old system that people used to also complain about on a weekly basis.