did we miss something with the hatton mayweather fight?

[:::PSL:::]

I had Hatton winning the fight before the stoppage.

[HattonTheHammer]

Hatton would of disposed of corrales no problems.

Guy was an excellent counter puncher who gave castillo problems in his prime.

But he wouldnt of lived with hatton, similar style only ricky would of made himself the aggressor and forced corrales into fighting a fight he wouldnt be used to.

The current haters are ten a plenty at the mo, sad really as hatton is one of the few boxers in the world at the moment who can win a genuine world title without being completely on song.

[DaxxKahn]

Hatton would of disposed of corrales no problems.

Guy was an excellent counter puncher who gave castillo problems in his prime.

But he wouldnt of lived with hatton, similar style only ricky would of made himself the aggressor and forced corrales into fighting a fight he wouldnt be used to.

The current haters are ten a plenty at the mo, sad really as hatton is one of the few boxers in the world at the moment who can win a genuine world title without being completely on song.

I would not go that far....And I also would not pick Hatton over a Prime Castillo....He beat a shop worn version that was obvious did not really want the fight to begin with....I liike Ricky but he is not as good as you are stating....Many guys in the game that would beat him P4P.....Even at 140 I still say Malignaggi outpoints him....

[leftylee]

Floyd and the ref tag teamed on Ricky, thats why he lost. He'll be back though.

[:::PSL:::]

Floyd and the ref tag teamed on Ricky, thats why he lost. He'll be back though.

Good to see you back mate!

[CFH]

Floyd and the ref tag teamed on Ricky, thats why he lost. He'll be back though.

He lost because Mayweather is a superior fighter in every aspect.

[leftylee]

Floyd and the ref tag teamed on Ricky, thats why he lost. He'll be back though.

He lost because Mayweather is a superior fighter in every aspect.

At elbowing and headbutt's I agree, check out Danny's vids he made, Floyd is "Counterfit Money".

[Unknowndonor]

I like Hatton, but he got wooped by Floyd. Nothing to be ashamed of, everyone else that has fought floyd has lost.

[CFH]

Floyd and the ref tag teamed on Ricky, thats why he lost. He'll be back though.

He lost because Mayweather is a superior fighter in every aspect.

At elbowing and headbutt's I agree, check out Danny's vids he made, Floyd is "Counterfit Money".

Every fighter cheats. Hatton cheats, last time I checked holding was as illegal as elbowing and butting. I also seem to recall Hatton landing a well-placed shot to Tszyu's balls, among his many other infractions.
None of that changes the fact that PBF is better than Hatton in every facet of the game. I like Hatton, I was hoping against all logic and reason that he could beat PBF, but if they fought 10 times, PBF would win 10 times, regardless of who the ref was.

[oakleyno1]

Hatton would of disposed of corrales no problems.

Guy was an excellent counter puncher who gave castillo problems in his prime.

But he wouldnt of lived with hatton, similar style only ricky would of made himself the aggressor and forced corrales into fighting a fight he wouldnt be used to.

The current haters are ten a plenty at the mo, sad really as hatton is one of the few boxers in the world at the moment who can win a genuine world title without being completely on song.

I would not go that far....And I also would not pick Hatton over a Prime Castillo....He beat a shop worn version that was obvious did not really want the fight to begin with....I liike Ricky but he is not as good as you are stating....Many guys in the game that would beat him P4P.....Even at 140 I still say Malignaggi outpoints him....

hopefully we will see on the 20th september de la hoya mayweather undercard :P haha how good would that be unfortunetly hatton can top any stage in the world so it wont happen. i think paulie is dangerous for anyone but i think hatton would beat both castillo and corrales with his ability to man handle people at 140. be long hard fights with both though, castillo espeshcialiy (cnt spell lol) corrales mayb 6 or 7 rounds

[DaxxKahn]

Hatton would of disposed of corrales no problems.

Guy was an excellent counter puncher who gave castillo problems in his prime.

But he wouldnt of lived with hatton, similar style only ricky would of made himself the aggressor and forced corrales into fighting a fight he wouldnt be used to.

The current haters are ten a plenty at the mo, sad really as hatton is one of the few boxers in the world at the moment who can win a genuine world title without being completely on song.

I would not go that far....And I also would not pick Hatton over a Prime Castillo....He beat a shop worn version that was obvious did not really want the fight to begin with....I liike Ricky but he is not as good as you are stating....Many guys in the game that would beat him P4P.....Even at 140 I still say Malignaggi outpoints him....

hopefully we will see on the 20th september de la hoya mayweather undercard :P haha how good would that be unfortunetly hatton can top any stage in the world so it wont happen. i think paulie is dangerous for anyone but i think hatton would beat both castillo and corrales with his ability to man handle people at 140. be long hard fights with both though, castillo espeshcialiy (cnt spell lol) corrales mayb 6 or 7 rounds

I don't know about all that...The version of Castillo that fought PBF the first time I can not see Hatton beating.The versions of Corrales and Castillo in their first fight is 1 are ones I don't see Hatton beating either

[Mikkel_K]

I don't know about all that...The version of Castillo that fought PBF the first time I can not see Hatton beating.The versions of Corrales and Castillo in their first fight is 1 are ones I don't see Hatton beating either

Honest question:

Do you see Corrales or Castillo being that effective (e.g. as good as they were in the fights you mentioned) at 140? Personally I dont really see it, and I would probably give Hatton a decent chance against both - even if the versions of them that you mentioned would be better than Hatton p4p. [Did that make any sense at all?]

[HattonTheHammer]

Hatton would of disposed of corrales no problems.

Guy was an excellent counter puncher who gave castillo problems in his prime.

But he wouldnt of lived with hatton, similar style only ricky would of made himself the aggressor and forced corrales into fighting a fight he wouldnt be used to.

The current haters are ten a plenty at the mo, sad really as hatton is one of the few boxers in the world at the moment who can win a genuine world title without being completely on song.

I would not go that far....And I also would not pick Hatton over a Prime Castillo....He beat a shop worn version that was obvious did not really want the fight to begin with....I liike Ricky but he is not as good as you are stating....Many guys in the game that would beat him P4P.....Even at 140 I still say Malignaggi outpoints him....

Castillo took the fight having just come off wins against corrales and ngoudjo. Nobody before the fight questioned his desire to be in the ring with hatton it was only after seeing him out classed by a better opponent and stopped through a beaut of a kidney shot that people began coming up with this ridiculous assesment that jose had just suddenly lost the hunger to win the exact same assesment people came to the same conclusion with when he beat tszyu despite the fact hatton walked through kostyas best punches that night.

Hatton can only beat what is ever infront of him and apart from the P4P king he has done that all his career.

corrales on the other hand - knocked out by castillo outboxed by casamayor and beaten in his final fight by some guy whos name i cant even remember!!

[killersheep]

Hatton would of disposed of corrales no problems.

Guy was an excellent counter puncher who gave castillo problems in his prime.

But he wouldnt of lived with hatton, similar style only ricky would of made himself the aggressor and forced corrales into fighting a fight he wouldnt be used to.

The current haters are ten a plenty at the mo, sad really as hatton is one of the few boxers in the world at the moment who can win a genuine world title without being completely on song.

I would not go that far....And I also would not pick Hatton over a Prime Castillo....He beat a shop worn version that was obvious did not really want the fight to begin with....I liike Ricky but he is not as good as you are stating....Many guys in the game that would beat him P4P.....Even at 140 I still say Malignaggi outpoints him....

Castillo took the fight having just come off wins against corrales and ngoudjo. Nobody before the fight questioned his desire to be in the ring with hatton it was only after seeing him out classed by a better opponent and stopped through a beaut of a kidney shot that people began coming up with this ridiculous assesment that jose had just suddenly lost the hunger to win the exact same assesment people came to the same conclusion with when he beat tszyu despite the fact hatton walked through kostyas best punches that night.

Hatton can only beat what is ever infront of him and apart from the P4P king he has done that all his career.

corrales on the other hand - knocked out by castillo outboxed by casamayor and beaten in his final fight by some guy whos name i cant even remember!!

Don't speak ill of the dead, please seriously. And many people questioned Castillo's desire to be in the ring during and after the Ngoudjo fight. He took 9 rounds off, certainly showed no desire, even considering the end result would be a shot at Hatton. Castillo's mind is fully cluttered by a lifetime of paying back debt, he has like 500 kids and has to pay the Corrales family for coming in over-weight for their rubber match.

[killersheep]

Hatton would of disposed of corrales no problems.

That's a bit of a stretch, to say anyone would have "no problems" against Corrales is a statement of someone that never watched his fights aside from maybe the Mayweather one.