To Me IF Floyd is Retired Joe Calzaghe is PFP#1

[amat]

I think P4P is based a lot of talent in which case, I can't make Calzaghe number 1. That would be saying he's the most talented fighter in the world essentially, and that's just not true. I think he's very beatable and Hopkins pretty much proved that. It's not like his record jumps out either I mean he has 3 really good wins and a ton of fights that ranged from meaning little to being somewhat impressive.

I would go so far that if Cotto were to beat Margarito convincingly, that I would put Pac at 1 and Cotto at 2. Cotto's resume is pretty much just as good as Calzaghe's imo.

[p4pking]

I think P4P is based a lot of talent in which case, I can't make Calzaghe number 1. That would be saying he's the most talented fighter in the world essentially, and that's just not true. I think he's very beatable and Hopkins pretty much proved that. It's not like his record jumps out either I mean he has 3 really good wins and a ton of fights that ranged from meaning little to being somewhat impressive.

I would go so far that if Cotto were to beat Margarito convincingly, that I would put Pac at 1 and Cotto at 2. Cotto's resume is pretty much just as good as Calzaghe's imo.

Cotto's resume is certainly a lot more impressive than Calzaghe's, when you take into account how far he is in his career and the number of quality fighters on his resume. I also personally think he is a better p4p fighter these days for many reaons, no doubt.

[piye]

Pacman is the number 1 now.

[brucelee]

After counting those who have voted for Pac and Cal, Pac wins the p4p title.

The debate should be, who's to be second? Cal or Cotto?

[GAME]

Yeah with Floyds retirement I guess this makes Calzaghe the worlds premiere fighter