One question came to mind after reading this thread:

Is Floyd or Roy Jones Jr. higher in the all time list?

Were RJJ to beat Calzaghe or were Floyd to beat Cotto (I don't believe in his retirement either), I'd say it was clear. Now I am actually not so sure. Roy Jones was damn near unbeatable at MW/SMW, but so was Floyd in a number of weights. I guess I'd still have RJJ higher, as his list of great wins is perhaps slightly longer, but how do you guys feel?

Coincidentally Roy Jones might actually be ranked higher had _he_ chosen to retire early (read: After beating Ruiz).