David Tua vs Sam Peter who would win right now?

[The Promoter]

If Tua is in shape (big if) he stops Peter...Sam Peter is succeptible to the left hook and uppercut as seen by Sam's fights with Wlad, Jameel and even Toney who froze Sam several times with the hook...are there many/any fighters today that throw better left hooks or uppercuts than Tua?

Sam Peter ain't no Chris Byrd and he will be easy for David to hit...Tua within 5 rounds by brutal KO...

[southakron314]

I see Peter backing up the whole fight and Tua knocking him out. 5th round.

[Wayne]

I think we're investing a little too much in what we saw when Peter fought McCline. Every single one of us saw in McCline a fighter who rarely, if ever, showed up. I'm saying without saying, that there is a specific reason for that that was hinted at in the pre-interview with McCline before the fight. McCline has never been that aggressive in any fight I've seen. Oh, and guess what? Peter took all of that anyway and still came back and won the fight decisively.

[rjj tszyu]

I think we're investing a little too much in what we saw when Peter fought McCline. Every single one of us saw in McCline a fighter who rarely, if ever, showed up. I'm saying without saying, that there is a specific reason for that that was hinted at in the pre-interview with McCline before the fight. McCline has never been that aggressive in any fight I've seen. Oh, and guess what? Peter took all of that anyway and still came back and won the fight decisively.

I agree totally! Peter flattened Klitschko 3 times but I doubt very much that would happen again. These things happen!

In his prime Tua would PROBABLY have won this fight but I doubt it now.

[SaltyBacon]

peter has a steady workwate to beat tua now

but prime tua

[USA LOVES THE KLITSCHKOS]

Tua and Peter both get hit alot but in the exchange of power shots I see Sam going down.If James Toney can rock Sam imagine what Tua would do. Tua by ko before rd5.

[El Kabong]

Sam Peter by UD right now but Tua in his prime....Sam's chin has been destroyed though