Margarito now #6....

[Fenster]

and going by most of the logic on here, shouldn't taylor of been #1 when he beat hopkins?

Exactly.

That proves judging P4P by "beat the man take his place" is about as flawed as you can get.

[ssss]

The real question is where was Antonio Margarito rated before the Miguel Cotto fight ? because im not even sure if he would of been in the top 20 P4P no offense.