A viewpoint that may prove unpopular. (Weights,Margarito, Castillo etc.)

[Thread Stealer]

I have a problem with the weigh-in rules, but I don't blame them on the fighters provided they make the weight fairly.

Some fighters have the ability and styles (and talent) to move up in weight and be successful.

DLH was big at the lighter weights, and had the skills and talent to be successful at the higher weights. He wasn't as powerful in the higher weights, but has always had that great left jab, left hook, solid fundamentals, etc...

Mayweather is another guy who was successful in numerous weight classes due to skills, style, and talent. Yes, Baldomir is slow as molasses, but he outweighed PBF by a dozen lbs on fight night. DLH had quite a size advantage on PBF as well.

Others who rely more on strength are less likely to be as successful in different weight classes.

It also shows how special Duran and Chavez were to be successful in different weight classes with pressure styles, and how they had other tricks in the bag other than being strong and tough. They had smarts and terrific skills.

[Mikkel_K]

Quite frankly I dont understand the question? Surely any fighter will (should) try to fight at the weight where he is most competitive? Doing so can never be unfair, can it?

[SigmaMu]

This is why hitmandonny.. and this is just my own opinion, based on what you have said, that..
Williams vs Margarito II should be made ASAP.
I remember Sergio Mora saying that Tony is the same size he is and Sergio has been fighting at 154 and 160.

As of late, Paul Williams has been calling out any one in FOUR different weight classes from 147 to 168 So, we know he is not going to just be fighting at 147.
Tony did pretty good against Santos.
Santos is a champ today again.
There are plenty of fights for Tony and Williams. It will be interesting what these guys do in the near future. I can't wait.
Is the weight thing fair? It is what it is
But I do hear what you are saying and your examples are pretty fair some people can move up and their style works, while others move up and look like shiet in the process.
There is no doubt in my mind, that Tony could move up to 154 and take on Mora they know each other very well Santos Margarito III would be a fight I would also like to see I don't know what else to say.

[killersheep]

I think same day weigh-ins should be more common place, with what Castillo was doing and let's face it most everyone lower than welter weight. The long term effects of dehydration cannot be ignored.

[donnydarkoIRL]

GREAT POST BY THE WAY!!! I was wanting to create one but my boxing knowledge is very limited and I'm scared to be criticized for making one.
If they are effective and healthy in the process why not, but in IMO I'd rather see two equally size fighters being pit together from the get go. Well It's just me.
Thats why I'm more prouder than ever before for Kelly Pavlik for steppin up in weight vs Taylor in the rematch and against Hopkins in Oct, Miguel Cotto for having the courage to step up in a welterweight division filled with guys 5'10" up being 5'7" himself and to Manny Pacquio for obvious reasons.

Absolutley, a man that even steps up one division to be succesful is above a "good fighter."

Good post

you can argue that size particular height is an advantage and in most cases it is, but if you don't have the skill to match the your size and you are against the right kind of fighter that advantage can be reversed

I remember watching Ricky Hatton fight a freak at LWW called Tony Pep I think he was Canadian he was limited but was about 6'1" and was made for Hatton, that long body for Hatton to break apart and Ricky closes distance in amazing speed.

But that was at LWW and we did see how exposed Hatton was at WW

Its most obvious when someone like Judda walks in to the ring at 143 and Clotty walks in at 150 + this is when it become difficult

One point I feel needs to be added is even a fighter killing himself to make the weight, will still be stronger when rehydrated and renourished, than a smaller guy at the weight.

Good point on Judah Clottey.

Donny i cant fault you at all, excellent post. Id give you an old fashion cool one if i could!

There are so many boxers who boil down to the lowest weight possible to either a) exploit their advantages or b) hide there own disadvantages.

Ricky Hatton for example boils down from 12st to hide the fact that he's a fat Kunt

Thank you Jim.

Thats a good analysis there.

I have a problem with the weigh-in rules, but I don't blame them on the fighters provided they make the weight fairly.

Some fighters have the ability and styles (and talent) to move up in weight and be successful.

DLH was big at the lighter weights, and had the skills and talent to be successful at the higher weights. He wasn't as powerful in the higher weights, but has always had that great left jab, left hook, solid fundamentals, etc...

Mayweather is another guy who was successful in numerous weight classes due to skills, style, and talent. Yes, Baldomir is slow as molasses, but he outweighed PBF by a dozen lbs on fight night. DLH had quite a size advantage on PBF as well.

Others who rely more on strength are less likely to be as successful in different weight classes.

It also shows how special Duran and Chavez were to be successful in different weight classes with pressure styles, and how they had other tricks in the bag other than being strong and tough. They had smarts and terrific skills.

I feel in this day and age, we may put too much pressure on our fighters to move up.
Perhaps as fans we are expecting too much for one fighter to rule a division and then attack another?
What do you think?

Quite frankly I dont understand the question? Surely any fighter will (should) try to fight at the weight where he is most competitive? Doing so can never be unfair, can it?

The point I raise is, often it is unhealthy to do this over prolonged periods of time, some may view it as an unfair advantage and if weigh ins were on the day quite simply these guys wouldn't do it.

This is why hitmandonny.. and this is just my own opinion, based on what you have said, that..
Williams vs Margarito II should be made ASAP.
I remember Sergio Mora saying that Tony is the same size he is and Sergio has been fighting at 154 and 160.

As of late, Paul Williams has been calling out any one in FOUR different weight classes from 147 to 168 So, we know he is not going to just be fighting at 147.
Tony did pretty good against Santos.
Santos is a champ today again.
There are plenty of fights for Tony and Williams. It will be interesting what these guys do in the near future. I can't wait.
Is the weight thing fair? It is what it is
But I do hear what you are saying and your examples are pretty fair some people can move up and their style works, while others move up and look like shiet in the process.
There is no doubt in my mind, that Tony could move up to 154 and take on Mora they know each other very well Santos Margarito III would be a fight I would also like to see I don't know what else to say.

Agreed on Williams Tony Williams certainly.

I never meant to discredit Tony.

I think same day weigh-ins should be more common place, with what Castillo was doing and let's face it most everyone lower than welter weight. The long term effects of dehydration cannot be ignored.

I too feel same day weigh ins would be a good idea.
Perhapos for non title bouts, leaving the title bouts as they are for championship reasons.

[Sharla]

I think same day weigh-ins should be more common place, with what Castillo was doing and let's face it most everyone lower than welter weight. The long term effects of dehydration cannot be ignored.

I too feel same day weigh ins would be a good idea.
Perhapos for non title bouts, leaving the title bouts as they are for championship reasons.

To be honest I'm not sure why you think same day weigh ins would be better?

I've had to weigh in straight before bouts (within an hour of competing) and I've weighed in a day before and I preferred having as much time between the weigh in and the bout as possible.

I'll always make the weight regardless of when the weigh in is but it's less draining physically and emotionally to get it out of the way a little earlier.

It leaves you with more energy and fully hydrated to put in a better performance on fight night. Perhaps that would translate to livlier, more action packed fights from a spectators point of view also?

Isn't competing dehydrated supposed to be one of the major things predisposing fighters to brain injury (not 100 % sure but i think i've heard/read that - maybe on here somewhere)?

Have the weigh in a day before and you decrease the likelyhood of people competing dehydrated at least surely?!

[donnydarkoIRL]

To be honest I'm not sure why you think same day weigh ins would be better?

I've had to weigh in straight before bouts (within an hour of competing) and I've weighed in a day before and I preferred having as much time between the weigh in and the bout as possible.

I'll always make the weight regardless of when the weigh in is but it's less draining physically and emotionally to get it out of the way a little earlier.

It leaves you with more energy and fully hydrated to put in a better performance on fight night. Perhaps that would translate to livlier, more action packed fights from a spectators point of view also?

Isn't competing dehydrated supposed to be one of the major things predisposing fighters to brain injury (not 100 % sure but i think i've heard/read that - maybe on here somewhere)?

Have the weigh in a day before and you decrease the likelyhood of people competing dehydrated at least surely?!

The idea was actually propsed in order to limit inury and dehydration.

The thought was that any sensible fighter would not attempt to drain themselves too much by making weight the day of a fight.
I know Castillo had he been forced to weigh in on the day, would never have competed at feather, superfeather or Lightweight, divisions he was a real threat in because of his huge size advantage.