What if Alfonso Gomez fought Zab Judah?

[ICB]

uh huh...

I think you guys are wrong in comparing their efforts against Cotto. That doesn't mean much here. They would be fighting each other, NOT Cotto again.

Gomez has a similar style to Baldomir, and pressure guys have been givin Judah real problems lately.

I think it would be a tough fight for Judah after the early rounds.

Baldo was/is a lot stronger and more durable than Gomez

Exactly Carlos Baldomir took Vernon Forrest's shots at 154 which shows he has a good chin and he is very strong, where as Alfonso Gomez has struggled with the likes of Jessie Felciano, Alfonso Gomez has questionable stamina, he has a soft midsection.

And he is pretty average all round and i wouldn't say he is that good of a pressure fighter either, i think he likes to box at mid distance using his jab. Zab Judah may have a weak mentality, but i cannot see him losing to someone of Alfonso Gomez's level.

[Kev]

uh huh...

I think you guys are wrong in comparing their efforts against Cotto. That doesn't mean much here. They would be fighting each other, NOT Cotto again.

Gomez has a similar style to Baldomir, and pressure guys have been givin Judah real problems lately.

I think it would be a tough fight for Judah after the early rounds.

Baldo was/is a lot stronger and more durable than Gomez

Exactly Carlos Baldomir took Vernon Forrest's shots at 154 which shows he has a good chin and he is very strong, where as Alfonso Gomez has struggled with the likes of Jessie Felciano, Alfonso Gomez has questionable stamina, he has a soft midsection.

And he is pretty average all round and i wouldn't say he is that good of a pressure fighter either, i think he likes to box at mid distance using his jab. Zab Judah may have a weak mentality, but i cannot see him losing to someone of Alfonso Gomez's level.

But Baldomir also scraped a rather dubious points win over that Perez guy who Gomez previously blew out in about 3 rounds.

Baldimor is just a fat plodder who is little more than a walking punch bag, I'd favour Gomez over Baldomir any day of the week, Gomez would completely outbox him

[eagle]

Baldo was/is a lot stronger and more durable than Gomez

Exactly Carlos Baldomir took Vernon Forrest's shots at 154 which shows he has a good chin and he is very strong, where as Alfonso Gomez has struggled with the likes of Jessie Felciano, Alfonso Gomez has questionable stamina, he has a soft midsection.

And he is pretty average all round and i wouldn't say he is that good of a pressure fighter either, i think he likes to box at mid distance using his jab. Zab Judah may have a weak mentality, but i cannot see him losing to someone of Alfonso Gomez's level.

But Baldomir also scraped a rather dubious points win over that Perez guy who Gomez previously blew out in about 3 rounds.

Baldimor is just a fat plodder who is little more than a walking punch bag, I'd favour Gomez over Baldomir any day of the week, Gomez would completely outbox him

The Baldo that beat Judah would bulldoze Gomez.

[C-Lo]

I'd go with Judah by decision