Call Me Crazy But I Want To See This

[JT Rock]

I don't think that's true. Both came in as fat blubbery messes imo. I love Toney one of my all time favourite fighters but he hasn't been in great shape since he beat Michael Nunn.

I figured you know it was prefaced with the fact that Toney struggles but came in at a stellar shape compared to the last Rahman, Peter and Batchelder fights... Matter of Fact I would take the Toney that beat Holyfield and Jirov to beat any heavy or Cruiser aside form Vitali Klitschko

Well I don't think he could have beaten Wlad either but on his day I think he'd have made it tough for any other non Klitschko out there.

Not sure how much he has left now though.

The Toney That dismantled Holyfield would have ate Wlads heart and would have toyed with Tyson as well..

[El Kabong]

The Toney That dismantled Holyfield would have ate Wlads heart and would have toyed with Tyson as well..

...you MUST be shrooming.

At the end of Tyson's career, YES James Toney would have been way too much defensively for him but NEVER EVER was James Toney going to "eat Wlad's Heart"......Wlad might not have KO'd him but he would have had an easy time with a points win over him

[JT Rock]

The Toney That dismantled Holyfield would have ate Wlads heart and would have toyed with Tyson as well..

...you MUST be shrooming.

At the end of Tyson's career, YES James Toney would have been way too much defensively for him but NEVER EVER was James Toney going to "eat Wlad's Heart"......Wlad might not have KO'd him but he would have had an easy time with a points win over him

No gotdam way Toney would have gotten in his head Shoulder rolled and out gutted Wlad leaving him off balance

[Mr140]

Big deal he beat Holyfeild a very old Holyfeild who looked to have a heart attack in the ring way overrated win if you ask me. I think a younger version of Holyfeild would of beat Tony to a lopsided decsion people i dont get it they seem not to see how bad Holyfeild was at the time lol.

[JT Rock]

Big deal he beat Holyfeild a very old Holyfeild who looked to have a heart attack in the ring way overrated win if you ask me. I think a younger version of Holyfeild would of beat Tony to a lopsided decsion people i dont get it they seem not to see how bad Holyfeild was at the time lol.

I am a the hugest Holyfield fan on this sight and Toney gives him absolute fits 10x out of 10... They are of a rare fraternity of old throw backs

[Mr140]

Holyfeild was 40 years old he had some years on Toney and alot more wars then Toney not to mention Holyfeild hart condition. What ever was left of Holyfeild was gone after Lewis fights he was done even before then Holyfeild had a tough career and it showed in the later half. He was one of my favorite fighters but he should of called it a long time ago he is to old and he was to old when he fought Toney sad part is Holyfeild still fighting now which i dont get at all.

[ICB]

I'll have to call you crazy on this one bro, this would be a ridiculous fight IMO. And i have no idea how Bernard Hopkins would be able to get above 200 pounds, and James Toney well lets be honest the last time he was in shape was when he fought Evander Holyfield.

Speaking of which JT i see you talking about Evander Holyfield vs James Toney, i also believe a prime James Toney would give a prime Evander Holyfield fits aswell, can you imagine them going at it prime for prime at Cruiserweight ? wow thats one of my dream match ups, along with James Toney vs Bernard Hopkins at Middleweight/Super Middleweight.

[JT Rock]

I'll have to call you crazy on this one bro, this would be a ridiculous fight IMO. And i have no idea how Bernard Hopkins would be able to get above 200 pounds, and James Toney well lets be honest the last time he was in shape was when he fought Evander Holyfield.

Speaking of which JT i see you talk about Evander Holyfield vs James Toney, i also believe a prime James Toney would give a prime Evander Holyfield fits aswell, can you imagine them going at it prime for prime at Cruiserweight ? wow.

Honestly its a pikem Evander has all the heart but James would fight beyond all the limitations, crazy to think these to just missed each other by a few years... Moorer gave him all the trouble 2 x bar when holy Knocked him down, albeit moorer was a south paw james had all the tangibles and intangibles as well as the toughness and ability to swim in the deep waters with Evander... Toney is an enigma to me and one of the greatest, want to see him leave on a high note... Love me some David Haye, but Toney would spoil him all day perfecyt retirement fight to go out on a high note....

There will never be another like James Toney and Bernard Hopkins

[El Kabong]

No gotdam way Toney would have gotten in his head Shoulder rolled and out gutted Wlad leaving him off balance

Would Toney have a bat or something? Because if not then there is no way Wlad let's James in punching range and even if he did what the hell would James do?

Wlad would have beaten that fat bastard up for 12 rounds NEVER LOSING ONE


and you're a fool to think otherwise....where's Toney now? James Toney couldn't even beat SAM PETER!!!!!