I dont hate calzaghe..

But my views contrast to yours as follows..

Personally i think Bernard beat Joey C.. I think joe fought bernards fight the whole 12 and while looking impressive considering he fought hopkins better then anyone other then roy jones.. i still think he lost and was pretty shocked by the cards.

Secondly just because Ex just schooled Kelly pavlik.. doesnt mean i count out kelly to beat calzaghe if they fought. i think styles make fights and i still give pavlik the same chance to beat joe.
just like the whole scenario between kelly, jermain taylor, bernard hopkins.. it doesnt cancel out the 'losses', but it just helps..

and yeah.. the whole caps thing doesnt make your opinions gospel..

your opinions are your opinions but extra emphasis doesnt make them true.

and frankly as far as legacy goes .. Bhop has the top spot of the 3 imo..
he's got a awesome resume.

then perhaps the winner of the jones - joey c fight takes second..
regardless of the winner i think Roy and joe have both missed out on big paydays and big events during their primes, Roy i feel gave more bang for buck and entertainment, fought better opposition.. and both have made up for the super fights they lacked early at the ends of their careers..

Its unfair but roy will get more credit for beating calzaghe then joe could get for beating roy.