Pernell Whitaker's Controversial Draws/Losses vs Controversial Wins.

[ICB]

Pernell Whitaker's Controversial Draws/Losses

Julio Cesar Chavez = Whitaker
ODLH = Draw
Jose Luis Ramirez 1 = Whitaker

Pernell Whitaker's Controversial Wins

Buddy McGirt 1 = Whitaker
Wilfredo Rivera 1 = Draw
Wilfredo Rivera 2 = Whiaker

In your opinion how should Pernell Whitaker's record be regarding these 6 fights ? just one thing i'll point out firstly, i don't see why the 2nd Wilfredo Rivera fight is considered controversial. I thought Pernell Whitaker won it pretty clearly IMO.

Pretty much the same but:

Rivera/whitaker 1= Rivera 115-113

Rivera/Whitaker 2= Whitaker 115-112 ? It looks a mess on the scoresheet,round 6 point deduction after 5th round KD (10-9 Rivera)?

I vaugly remember Vasquez not getting a KD when Whitaker was going into his squating technique??Butt hit the canvas or something

Julio Cesar Vasquez did get a KD scored over Pernell Whitaker.