fighter of 2008 so far

[kingfrnk]

Margarito for me with the Cintron and Cotto wins.

agree. but i chose chad dawson he beat glen and tarver who had two fights together themselves. so thats my choice

[Kev]

I'l go with Margarito, he won the most significant fight of the year and without controversy.

I'm still baffled at how people can think Hopkins is more deserving of fighter of the year than Calzaghe.

Calzaghe's win is taken as a moral defeat it seems in the eyes of many whilst Hopkins actually gets credit for keeping it close.

Calzahge beat Hopkins so how can Hopkins be ahead of him in the fighter of the year stakes

[C-Lo]

Margarito for me with the Cintron and Cotto wins.

agree. but i chose chad dawson he beat glen and tarver who had two fights together themselves. so thats my choice

Chad has had a good year but he still isn't a mainstream name which is why I think he won't get the nod for Fighter of the Year.